Andrii-zvorygin Peak-oil Meeting Transcript — November 12, 2026
Hook: Oil depletion drives inflation as markets fail to predict price spikes.
Andrii-zvorygin · Peak-oil · November 12, 2026
Summary
Whole Stream Summary Speakers analyse Philip Pilkington's projection that oil prices will inevitably reach $126 per barrel by June 2027 due to reserve depletion, arguing that declining energy availability directly increases living costs and drives inflation through the drawdown of U.S. stocks like the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. The discussion challenges conventional supply-and-demand models, presenting data that suggests inventory levels predict prices more effectively than production or consumption flows, while noting that recent geopolitical disruptions in the Persian Gulf have failed to trigger expected price spikes due to market financialization and hedging practices. Furthermore, participants explore the thermodynamic limits of energy conversion, proposing that renewables function only as marginal diversity sources rather than primary power solutions, and suggest structural changes such as localizing grid control to address instability caused by increasing device counts in the current system. The conversation further explores the limitations of emissions reduction strategies due to the longevity of atmospheric carbon dioxide and critiques inefficient practices like corn ethanol, proposing alternatives such as rural transitions, syngas technology, and local adaptation to complex adaptive systems instead of attempting to fix inherently unstable economic or environmental structures.
Top Newsworthy Developments
- Entropy Law Limits Energy Efficiency and Power: One participant explains that only about half of the energy from a barrel of oil converts into useful work because the rest is lost as heat. This process transforms free energy into stable bound energy like carbon dioxide and water, which cannot be easily reused for civilization.
- Oil Reserves Versus Inventory Debate: Speakers discuss the discrepancy between government-reported oil reserves and actual company data, noting that undiscovered resources often lie in expensive locations. They suggest that rising extraction costs will cause energy prices to steadily increase over time.
- Economic Limits of Extracting Ground Oil: Speakers discuss how two-thirds of subsurface oil remains economically unviable to extract due to high costs and energy requirements. One participant cites a failed Halliburton project in Wyoming where carbon dioxide injection improved production by only four percent before leaking into a school caused shutdowns.
- Climate Change Impacts on Agriculture and Wildlife: Speakers discuss how changing weather patterns disrupt local ecosystems, causing fruit trees to fail and snowmobile trails to disappear due to insufficient snow. They note that some industry participants are adapting their businesses to these new realities while others struggle to accept the shift away from resource growth scenarios.
- Adapting Freight Transport With Sails And Biodiesel: Speakers discuss adapting freight transport by using biodiesel for efficient rail locomotives that avoid sulfur emissions. They also describe large cargo ships deploying sails to capture trade winds and significantly reduce diesel fuel consumption.
- Geothermal Power for Off-Grid Towns: One participant presents a formula for creating self-sufficient towns powered by geothermal energy, estimating that 55 thousand houses require one hundred megawatts of power. The speaker argues this approach provides cheap energy necessary for reindustrialization and is more affordable than commonly assumed.
Key Topics & Sections
Meeting Details
- Jurisdiction
- Andrii-zvorygin
- Body
- Peak-oil
- Date
- November 12, 2026
- Transcript Status
- Machine transcription, lightly cleaned
- Official Source
- View official meeting page
- Agenda Page
- View agenda page
- Original Video
- View original meeting video
- Meeting Portal
- View eScribe meeting page
Related Discussion
HelpOS discussion thread link pending.
Transcript Notice
This transcript was generated automatically and may contain errors in wording, speaker identification, punctuation, or timestamps.
It is an unofficial convenience copy provided for reading and searchability.
For the official record, refer to the original source materials published by the relevant authority, including the official video, agenda, minutes, and meeting records.
Full Transcript
Oil Price Projections and Economic Impact
Speakers discuss Philip Pilkington's projection that oil prices will inevitably rise to $126 per barrel by June 2027 due to continued depletion of reserves. One participant explains that decreasing energy availability directly increases the cost of living and economic activity, linking debt levels to future work capacity. The conversation concludes with observations on how depleting U.S. crude and product stocks, including the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, drives inflation upward.
00:00:00 SPEAKER_UNKNOWN: Greetings and love and light of the Infinite Creator.
00:00:03 SPEAKER_UNKNOWN: I'm Andrei Borgin.
00:00:04 SPEAKER_UNKNOWN: Joined here today with Iver and Peter Sternlight and John Day.
00:00:07 SPEAKER_002: Art had some car issues, but hopefully he'll be able to join us in ten minutes or so.
00:00:12 SPEAKER_002: We'll be talking about oil, and Iver has some updates for us.
00:00:18 SPEAKER_002: Meanwhile, go ahead, Iver.
00:00:19 SPEAKER_002: Sure.
00:00:20 SPEAKER_002: Are we live already?
00:00:20 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
00:00:21 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, we're live.
00:00:22 SPEAKER_002: Okay.
00:00:22 SPEAKER_002: Well, I just saw this really interesting.
00:00:25 SPEAKER_002: Do you know Mario Nolfal?
00:00:26 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
00:00:28 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
00:00:29 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
00:00:29 SPEAKER_002: He was interviewing Philip Pilkington, and they did some great kind of clowning around.
00:00:33 SPEAKER_002: You know, they're fun.
00:00:34 SPEAKER_004: They kind of like hack around a little, and then about ten minutes into Philip Pilkington's presentation, he had something very interesting to say.
00:00:44 SPEAKER_004: He thinks that oil is going to go to about $120 a barrel, no matter what we do, and it could be worse.
00:00:51 SPEAKER_004: This is Q1 of 2027.
00:00:55 SPEAKER_004: He said basically: Our dear leader, whose name shall remain nameless, has to—he has to get congressional authorization to pump the S, the Strategic Petroleum Reserve,
00:01:15 SPEAKER_004: down below the levels that it's soon going to be at.
00:01:19 SPEAKER_004: So even if he gets this permission, it may not hold it off for very long.
00:01:26 SPEAKER_004: But basically, he said $120 a barrel oil or more could go up further than that, and he also said this is also going to push bond yields.
00:01:40 SPEAKER_004: You know, we have to in the United States; we have to sell our Treasury bonds in order to hold the whole thing up.
00:01:48 SPEAKER_004: So basically, he said in order to get people to buy these Treasuries, it could go up to almost over six percent bond yields, and yeah, this is perfect.
00:01:59 SPEAKER_004: This is exactly what he's projecting.
00:02:01 SPEAKER_004: This is Pilkington's projection.
00:02:03 SPEAKER_004: It's really interesting because he basically says it's sort of inevitable, and so he shows what the oil price could go to.
00:02:13 SPEAKER_004: And this is a really good one too.
00:02:14 SPEAKER_004: That was the other one I was looking at.
00:02:17 SPEAKER_004: Basically, it's there's almost no way out of this.
00:02:24 SPEAKER_004: Now I know that Andrei is going to come along, and I mean not Andrei, Art is going to come along and maybe have a whole different take on it.
00:02:33 SPEAKER_004: But it does seem like the dollar is getting stronger, which sounds good, except that the dollar we have to pay back these inflated dollars.
00:02:47 SPEAKER_004: So we actually kind of—the only way to kind of get out of our debt trap is to sell.
00:02:53 SPEAKER_004: You know, you know, to get rid of the debt at lower interest rates, and to be able to pay the interest on our debt.
00:03:02 SPEAKER_004: So we need to have this kind of...
00:03:05 SPEAKER_004: It's interesting the way that oil is directly related to our economic problems.
00:03:10 SPEAKER_004: Yeah.
00:03:11 SPEAKER_004: So we need to figure out something and figure it out kind of soon because if you look at Philip Pilkington's graph, it's almost—he shows it as kind of inevitable.
00:03:25 SPEAKER_004: October 2026, he said $96, $94, and by the time he hit June 2027, it's $126, $150.
00:03:32 SPEAKER_004: Now that's all projections, and it's based on the reserves being continued depleting.
00:03:39 SPEAKER_004: Graph is going from right to left.
00:03:42 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, yeah, exactly.
00:03:44 SPEAKER_002: And so that this is a graph of how much U.S. crude and product stocks, including SPR, there are I think in the world or something, and then if when it goes lower,
00:04:01 SPEAKER_002: the price goes up, and right now they're depleting those reserves, and so the price is going up, and if they deplete it further, the price will continue to go up.
00:04:11 SPEAKER_002: So Andrei, Peter here.
00:04:14 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, well, one of the things is that, and this is—it's stems from some work that I did with Simon Getting Old.
00:04:25 SPEAKER_002: It's Simon.
00:04:26 SPEAKER_002: Thank you.
00:04:28 SPEAKER_002: Is that the economy and the available energy to consume are directly linked?
00:04:35 SPEAKER_002: So as energy becomes less available, the price is going to go up.
00:04:45 SPEAKER_002: Debt is debt is—a is a proxy for energy.
00:04:49 SPEAKER_006: It is it is a promise for work to be done in the future.
00:04:53 SPEAKER_006: I mean, all of energy is—is—is—the ability to do work.
00:04:58 SPEAKER_006: We measure work in dollars, and that's our GDP.
00:05:03 SPEAKER_006: So as the availability of energy decreases, you know, the cost of living and the cost of our economy is going to increase proportionally.
00:05:17 SPEAKER_006: Yes, that makes sense.
00:05:19 SPEAKER_006: Yeah, that makes total sense.
00:05:22 SPEAKER_002: And yeah, he did have a graph here on the inflation aspects and how much inflation.
00:05:35 SPEAKER_002: So the green part was how much oil the price of oil is adding to inflation, and then the yellow and the blue, some other aspect.
00:05:48 SPEAKER_002: It's just not quite clear in these charts he has.
00:05:52 SPEAKER_002: But yeah, yeah.
Petroleum Flow Rates and Economic Impact
Speakers discuss how rising energy prices increase the cost of producing all other goods, noting Hawaii's heavy reliance on liquid fuels for its economy. Participants debate whether recent claims about restored oil flows after geopolitical conflicts are propaganda or reality, with one speaker suggesting that maintaining calm is an illusion while reserves dwindle. The conversation concludes by linking these deteriorating energy conditions to broader environmental degradation and the increasing uninhabitability of coastal regions due to climate change.
00:05:56 SPEAKER_002: So as energy goes up, then the price of everything goes up because we use energy in order to produce everything else.
00:06:02 SPEAKER_002: And even though energy is like John Peach was saying three to four percent of the economy.
00:06:08 SPEAKER_002: But without it, we don't have the rest.
00:06:11 SPEAKER_006: Well, I mean, for instance, I live—I live in Hawaii, and what's really amazing.
00:06:18 SPEAKER_006: I mean, we're as far as the United States goes, we're the only state that, well, probably Alaska, maybe to some degree, but 92 percent of our economy in Hawaii is based on petroleum flows.
00:06:34 SPEAKER_006: So we generate most of our electricity with petroleum.
00:06:38 SPEAKER_006: Our economy largely tourism and the military, is all liquid.
00:06:43 SPEAKER_006: You know, liquid fuels.
00:06:45 SPEAKER_006: It's this kind of thing with availability of oil, is a massive hit to where we live.
00:06:55 SPEAKER_006: Hmm.
00:06:57 SPEAKER_006: Yeah.
00:06:58 SPEAKER_002: And we know that with the Iran War, but they were saying that the flows have come back to normal?
00:07:09 SPEAKER_002: Was that?
00:07:10 SPEAKER_002: Am I?
00:07:11 SPEAKER_002: Was that just propaganda?
00:07:16 SPEAKER_002: Got to be propaganda.
00:07:17 SPEAKER_002: That would be my guess too.
00:07:19 SPEAKER_004: It's got to be propaganda because the thing about it is, if you think about it, they blew up a few tankers just the other day, and you know,
00:07:29 SPEAKER_004: you think about 100 million barrels a day.
00:07:32 SPEAKER_004: I mean, roughly, we need every day, right?
00:07:34 SPEAKER_004: And they took out at least 20 percent.
00:07:38 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, and it's been out for a long, long time.
00:07:42 SPEAKER_004: So there's no way that you fix that flow back up.
00:07:45 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, just quickly.
00:07:46 SPEAKER_004: And that's—I think what Pilkington was basically saying is we hit the end of our reserves here pretty soon, maybe nowish, you know, and then things go a little haywire.
00:07:58 SPEAKER_006: So about 20 years ago, now I did an interview with Matthew Simmons, the late great Matthew Simmons, and yeah, one of the things that I,
00:08:12 SPEAKER_006: one of the concepts that he introduced me to for the very first time in my life was the concept of flow rate.
00:08:19 SPEAKER_006: Okay, we measure energy as a flow against time.
00:08:25 SPEAKER_006: Okay, so we measure barrels per day, kilowatts per hour, etc., etc. There is absolutely no way that the flow rate of petroleum, with the ease of flow in these tankers, has found alternate routes,
00:08:42 SPEAKER_006: and certainly not routes that are going to impact the cost.
00:08:50 SPEAKER_006: So demand continues to rise, and you know, the costs are continuing to go up.
00:08:58 SPEAKER_006: I—I—I mean, I don't have any empirical data, but there's no way in my mind I can justify saying we're back to normal.
00:09:11 SPEAKER_004: I think that's the illusion that we're trying to sort of sell is the idea that we are going to get back to normal relatively soonish,
00:09:19 SPEAKER_004: and everybody's going to you know start booking tickets and flying around, etc. And I think it's just to keep everybody—you know, keep everybody kind of calm, you know, like the violence on the Titanic,
00:09:32 SPEAKER_004: you know, you kind of want to keep everybody.
00:09:35 SPEAKER_004: You know, we're going to have a big Christmas season, etc. And I think that's good.
00:09:39 SPEAKER_004: I mean, I personally, I'm sorry, but I don't—you know, I'm believe it or not, I'm getting kind of tired of doom.
00:09:46 SPEAKER_004: You know, and I don't really want to see—I'd like to see business as usual continue.
00:09:52 SPEAKER_004: You know, as long as possible, even if it's kind of an illusion.
00:09:56 SPEAKER_004: But I think he's right that we're not going to be able to hold this place up the way we.
00:10:03 SPEAKER_004: No, I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm there with you.
00:10:07 SPEAKER_006: Even if it's—even if it's—if it's adopting the don't look up final dinner.
00:10:13 SPEAKER_006: Yeah.
00:10:14 SPEAKER_006: Yes.
00:10:15 SPEAKER_006: You know, I mean, we've got X amount of time.
00:10:18 SPEAKER_006: How do you want to experience it, and you know, find the silver lining somewhere because this is certainly something that is much bigger than any one of us can influence.
00:10:31 SPEAKER_006: Yeah.
00:10:31 SPEAKER_006: Can you can you guys hear me?
00:10:33 SPEAKER_006: Yes.
00:10:34 SPEAKER_006: Yes, we can hear you, John.
00:10:36 SPEAKER_006: Look, let me—I just like to say something a bit different.
00:10:39 SPEAKER_006: Go ahead.
00:10:40 SPEAKER_006: You know, I'd like to see someone work into here.
00:10:45 SPEAKER_010: You know what we're seeing in the natural world, the biosphere, this massive degradation of the—all the ultimate sources that support us, and at the same time that—and at the same time,
00:10:56 SPEAKER_010: the climate news just gets worse and worse, and we're moving to a period over the next decade where more and more of the world is going to be almost uninhabitable.
00:11:06 SPEAKER_010: And I'd like to see us talk about how you can interweave that in there.
00:11:13 SPEAKER_010: You know, I don't know if you kept up with what's going on in Louisiana, but Musk has got a Starlink thing programmed right out in the coastal marshes, right on the coast.
00:11:23 SPEAKER_010: It is right on the coast where Hurricane Five hits sort of regularly nowadays, and sea level is going to rise by a metre by the end of the century,
00:11:33 SPEAKER_010: and all of this stuff is going to interact with this, you know, as these guys are saying, deteriorating energy situation, and I, you know,
00:11:44 SPEAKER_010: we got to get somebody on here who can really talk about that.
Persian Gulf Disruptions and Muted Oil Prices
The speaker discusses how recent conflicts in the Persian Gulf have created global supply interruptions for petroleum and related commodities. He notes that despite these significant events, oil prices have not risen as aggressively as expected since the 1970s. The presentation highlights confusion regarding why market reactions to such major disruptions remain muted compared to historical precedents.
00:11:48 SPEAKER_010: I read a lot about it, but one of John's, one of the things we're doing here in Hawaii is we live on islands,
00:11:59 SPEAKER_006: and so our energy infrastructure is completely siloed within the shores of each island.
00:12:07 SPEAKER_006: We don't load share.
00:12:12 SPEAKER_006: The utilities have to serve everyone, and so the focus is local.
00:12:18 SPEAKER_006: Hey, hey, Art, is it local self-sufficiency?
00:12:24 SPEAKER_006: And you know, the greater influence being the economy, and the strive for continuous growth is driving that resource depletion.
00:12:34 SPEAKER_006: Here, what we're doing, you know, what at least some of us are trying to do, even on a level of discussing with our state legislators is the idea of self-sufficiency.
00:12:50 SPEAKER_006: We need to minimize our imports, be able to take care of ourselves, and doing that on a global level is probably not something that we're going to be able to influence.
00:13:00 SPEAKER_006: But it is something we can do within the confines of each individual island.
00:13:06 SPEAKER_006: Thank you, Peter.
00:13:07 SPEAKER_006: So I want to say hi to Art.
00:13:08 SPEAKER_006: Thank you for making it.
00:13:11 SPEAKER_006: Sure.
00:13:11 SPEAKER_006: Okay.
00:13:13 SPEAKER_006: It's a little bit hard.
00:13:20 SPEAKER_002: Can you try turning off your video?
00:13:22 SPEAKER_002: Then maybe at least the audio will come through.
00:13:27 SPEAKER_002: Okay.
00:13:27 SPEAKER_002: Let's see.
00:13:28 SPEAKER_002: How's that?
00:13:29 SPEAKER_002: Okay, that's good.
00:13:30 SPEAKER_002: Okay.
00:13:30 SPEAKER_002: All right.
00:13:32 SPEAKER_002: So I've got your presentation here.
00:13:35 SPEAKER_002: Did you want to start with a brief intro about yourself, maybe?
00:13:42 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, sure.
00:13:43 SPEAKER_002: And you'll have to do my slides for me, obviously.
00:13:45 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
00:13:45 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
00:13:46 SPEAKER_002: Okay.
00:13:47 SPEAKER_002: I got them on the screen.
00:13:48 SPEAKER_002: You should be okay.
00:13:49 SPEAKER_002: So, I'm Art Berman.
00:13:51 SPEAKER_002: For those who don't know you, I'm a petroleum geologist.
00:13:55 SPEAKER_011: I've been doing consulting in the broader energy space for 25 years, and have gotten into a lot of areas that are actually related to energy, but not.
00:14:16 SPEAKER_011: All right.
00:14:18 SPEAKER_011: So today, I'm going to talk briefly about some of the systems work that I've been doing lately, and the background on this research and the presentation that I will show is the Iran War,
00:14:39 SPEAKER_011: the disruptions in the Persian Gulf and the Strait of Hormuz have created quite a global situation, as I think most of you know.
00:14:56 SPEAKER_011: And in the area of petroleum and the kinds of discussions that I'm engaged in, there's been a very high level of confusion, even frustration,
00:15:11 SPEAKER_011: with why oil prices haven't responded in a more aggressive way to what is, you know, by any estimation, the greatest interruption to the oil and petroleum, and oh, by the way,
00:15:28 SPEAKER_011: LNG and fertilizer and helium and sulfur and food and all kinds of other commodities.
00:15:36 SPEAKER_011: Certainly since the 1970s, and possibly even greater.
00:15:41 SPEAKER_011: So, my first slide is just a reminder that probably we don't know the petroleum system nearly as well as many of us think we do.
00:15:56 SPEAKER_011: And I say that from my own perspective.
00:16:00 SPEAKER_011: That one of the reasons I did this research was that after almost fifty years of being in this industry, I had to acknowledge: you know,
00:16:12 SPEAKER_011: I probably don't understand it as well as I think I do.
00:16:18 SPEAKER_011: The man that's in the first slide is a guy named Russell Ackoff, who was actually a professor at Wharton College in Philadelphia in the business school,
00:16:32 SPEAKER_011: and he was one of the early systems dynamics thinkers.
00:16:37 SPEAKER_011: And I've got a quote down at the bottom from him saying, "A system is never the sum of its parts; it's the product of their interactions."
00:16:46 SPEAKER_011: So the first real slide then shows Brent futures prices from I think like 1990s.
00:16:56 SPEAKER_011: I'm sorry, 2020 through just a couple of days ago, and what you can see is that there was a spike in 2022 that was the Ukraine war and the disruptions that caused,
00:17:14 SPEAKER_011: and then the spikes toward the right hand side of the chart are related to the current problems in the Persian Gulf.
00:17:24 SPEAKER_011: And what I'm showing there, the orange line is just the average price, which is something like you know 80 some odd dollars a barrel.
Supply Demand Balance Does Not Predict Price
The speaker argues that the petroleum system operates differently from human expectations regarding oil prices. Although analysts rely heavily on supply and demand balances to forecast market trends, data shows this method fails to predict price movements effectively. The presentation demonstrates that while production and consumption correlate strongly with each other, their balance has less than one percent correlation with actual price changes.
00:17:33 SPEAKER_011: And so the kinds of questions that people are asking is you know why isn't oil 150 or why isn't oil 200 because you know at one point we'd lost 20 million barrels a day of
00:17:49 SPEAKER_011: supply and some of that maybe a lot of it has come back but it's come back at a substantial premium;
00:17:59 SPEAKER_011: it's costing a lot more to get the oil out.
00:18:01 SPEAKER_011: I can go into that later if you like, but the bottom line is that you know it went up to about one hundred and seventeen dollars early on, fell back down into the upper eighties,
00:18:14 SPEAKER_011: lower nineties, where it pretty much stayed until just very recently when it went back up to those levels, and now it's fallen once again.
00:18:25 SPEAKER_011: So my comment is after doing this study that people care a lot about oil price, but the petroleum system doesn't care nearly as much about price as people do.
00:18:44 SPEAKER_011: Or, to put it differently, it cares differently than we do.
00:18:50 SPEAKER_011: So, if we go to the third slide, the main way that most people and certainly analysts look at oil systems is from the perspective of supply and demand, or production and consumption.
00:19:08 SPEAKER_011: They're only very slightly different, and again, I'll be glad to discuss what those differences are.
00:19:14 SPEAKER_011: But for now, let's just say they're sort of synonymous.
00:19:17 SPEAKER_011: And so, generally, what happens is that every month or so, the IEA and OPEC and EIA and various other agencies release their estimates of production and consumption.
00:19:35 SPEAKER_011: We take a look at those, subtract one from the other, usually consumption from production or demand from supply, whatever you want to call it, and you come up with a balance.
00:19:47 SPEAKER_011: And if that balance is positive, in other words, there's a surplus or a projected surplus, then the idea is, oh, you know, we got an oil glut or something approaching it.
00:19:58 SPEAKER_011: Price is going to go down.
00:20:00 SPEAKER_011: The inverse is equally true.
00:20:02 SPEAKER_011: If there's a supply-demand deficit, then the thinking is okay.
00:20:07 SPEAKER_011: That means that price is going to go up.
00:20:10 SPEAKER_011: So the first two charts, all I've done there is simply for the last, you know, I can't remember how many years because I'm on my phone and not my computer, but you know,
00:20:21 SPEAKER_011: like fifty years.
00:20:24 SPEAKER_011: If you cross plot price and I think the first one is production.
00:20:30 SPEAKER_011: What you see is that, and price is on the right, the y-axis.
00:20:37 SPEAKER_011: There's a tremendous variation in oil price, and not very much variation in the actual numbers of barrels per day that are available.
00:20:49 SPEAKER_011: And it's interesting because there are two families or two groupings.
00:20:54 SPEAKER_011: There's the orange one, which is before 2014, and then there's the blue one, which is after 2014.
00:21:02 SPEAKER_011: And I'll talk a little bit about what that may mean, but that's just what the data says.
00:21:08 SPEAKER_011: If you go to the next slide on the right, it's the same pattern, except this time we're looking at consumption.
00:21:15 SPEAKER_011: So price has gone through a tremendous variation on the y-axis.
00:21:20 SPEAKER_011: Not too much happening in terms of what's happening to the barrels a day of consumption or demand,
00:21:29 SPEAKER_011: and then the third chart in the centre on the bottom is simply a cross plot of supply and demand or consumption and production, and that is like as perfect a correlation, a statistical correlation,
00:21:44 SPEAKER_011: as you could ever get.
00:21:46 SPEAKER_011: I mean, it's an R squared of you know point...
00:21:49 SPEAKER_011: I can't.
00:21:49 SPEAKER_011: I think it's point nine five.
00:21:51 SPEAKER_011: That says that ninety five percent of the time that correlation, you know, the supply anticipates demand.
00:22:01 SPEAKER_011: So, so the point of all this is that supply and demand correlate beautifully with each other, but they really don't tell us very much, at least from my perspective, about price.
00:22:17 SPEAKER_011: So, if we go on to the third slide, I actually plotted supply-demand balance again: you know,
00:22:25 SPEAKER_011: the demand or the consumption minus the supply or the production versus... and I just cross plotted them together and this is from I think it's like the last since 2000 beginning of 2015 so eleven
00:22:41 SPEAKER_011: years and the correlation is... but there is no correlation.
00:22:49 SPEAKER_011: Less than one percent of the time, supply-demand balance predicts price.
00:22:53 SPEAKER_011: Is what that chart says.
00:22:54 SPEAKER_011: So that's you know that that really makes you wonder.
00:22:59 SPEAKER_011: Well, so why exactly do analysts rely on this so much?
00:23:05 SPEAKER_011: And this is not the first time I've pointed this out, but nonetheless, that is what they do.
00:23:11 SPEAKER_011: And so the question then is, well, you know, it's logical that a supply-demand balance should anticipate price?
00:23:20 SPEAKER_011: Why doesn't it?
Petroleum System Stocks and Flows Explained
The speaker explains that petroleum systems are defined by stocks like reserves and inventories rather than flows such as production and consumption. A correlation analysis shows that inventory levels predict price better than traditional supply and demand metrics. The discussion highlights that reported inventories carry significant uncertainty because some nations do not disclose their stock levels.
00:23:21 SPEAKER_011: So, if we go on to the next slide, the reason for that is that if we analyse petroleum from a systems dynamic perspective, there are two components or two main components of any system,
00:23:38 SPEAKER_011: whether it's petroleum, language, population, you know, whatever you want to talk about, and the two components are stocks and flows.
00:23:48 SPEAKER_011: And so in the petroleum world, stocks are oil fields and their reserves, and the fuels and feedstocks that are kept in inventory, whether they be commercial or strategic or whatever.
00:24:06 SPEAKER_011: Okay, those are what are called the state variables.
00:24:10 SPEAKER_011: Those are the things that systems people say that's what defines the system.
00:24:15 SPEAKER_011: And then there's flows: the flows that come out of those fields and reserves, and the flows that come out of those inventories, and those are production and consumption.
00:24:26 SPEAKER_011: And so, what a systems dynamics expert would say is, "Oh, well, the problem is that you're measuring the wrong thing.
00:24:34 SPEAKER_011: Supply and demand are flows; they're not stocks.
00:24:37 SPEAKER_011: It's stocks that actually define the system."
00:24:40 SPEAKER_011: And so, the graph then that's below is of inventories, and it happens to be comparative inventory.
00:24:50 SPEAKER_011: So all I did there was just subtract the five year average inventory, and I think that's for OECD or something like that from the current value.
00:25:04 SPEAKER_011: And when I do a correlation there, it's pretty darn good.
00:25:08 SPEAKER_011: It's an R squared of point six eight.
00:25:11 SPEAKER_011: Certainly a lot better than point zero zero four.
00:25:14 SPEAKER_011: So inventories, in some way or another, are a much better predictor of price than supply and demand.
00:25:25 SPEAKER_011: And a systems dynamics person would say, well, of course it is because you're looking at a stock.
00:25:31 SPEAKER_011: and not a flow.
00:25:34 SPEAKER_011: So if we move on to the next slide, then this is one that I modified from Donella Meadows who published a book in I think it was 2008 called Thinking in Systems.
00:25:46 SPEAKER_011: This is the same Donella Meadows that was the lead author on the Limits to Growth report.
00:25:52 SPEAKER_011: I can't remember was 1972 or 1973.
00:25:56 SPEAKER_011: The so-called Club of Rome, quite an impressive scientist.
00:26:01 SPEAKER_011: Whatever you may think about the Limits to Growth, and so this was a diagram that she created.
00:26:08 SPEAKER_011: It wasn't specifically for oil.
00:26:11 SPEAKER_011: I kind of modified it to make it be oil, and I guess you know the question in looking at that: the boxes there then are stocks, and the little valves with the arrows are flows.
00:26:26 SPEAKER_011: So here we're looking at different kinds of stocks.
00:26:29 SPEAKER_011: We are looking at oil field resources, but we're also looking at capital stocks, which is another kind of stock: oil drilling and refining capital, and various other things.
00:26:39 SPEAKER_011: And so the question then you ask is, well, where's price?
00:26:45 SPEAKER_011: And you have to look pretty hard because price kind of sneaks its way in about halfway up the diagram on the left, and price is simply not a principal variable.
00:26:59 SPEAKER_011: It's part of a feedback loop.
00:27:01 SPEAKER_011: It's important; I'm not saying it isn't.
00:27:04 SPEAKER_011: It's just not part of what defines a petroleum system, and so that's why I said to begin with, price matters, but it's not a principal system variable,
00:27:15 SPEAKER_011: and we humans don't think about it that way.
00:27:19 SPEAKER_011: But we need to learn.
00:27:21 SPEAKER_011: That's why I called the talk "Getting to Know the Petroleum System."
00:27:26 SPEAKER_011: We have to know what it is that we're dealing with.
00:27:29 SPEAKER_011: So the next slide: I actually took the four system variables—the stocks and flows, production, consumption, reserves, and inventories—and I plotted them as a time series.
00:27:47 SPEAKER_011: And when you first look at this, I mean, I guess the first conclusion you come to is, wow, everything keeps going up, one way or another.
00:28:01 SPEAKER_011: Everything is rising in time.
00:28:03 SPEAKER_011: Now there is an exception, and that is the purple line, which is inventories, which have dropped since about 2016.
00:28:14 SPEAKER_011: So I guess the first thing you could say is, well, what is the petroleum system, or what is its purpose?
00:28:21 SPEAKER_011: And this graph would tell you.
00:28:24 SPEAKER_011: I don't know, but the right word is persistence.
00:28:28 SPEAKER_011: So to put that in language: the behaviour of the system, whatever it is, is characterized by the long-term expansion of stocks and flows, with some ups and downs,
00:28:43 SPEAKER_011: and the one variation that I talked about.
00:28:46 SPEAKER_011: Now, you might notice that I've called that purple line "reported inventories," and that's because, of all of these variables, inventories are the one that has the most uncertainty around it,
00:29:03 SPEAKER_011: and there's a lot of reasons for that.
00:29:06 SPEAKER_011: But just to give you one example: I mean, China doesn't tell us what its inventories are.
00:29:11 SPEAKER_011: We know that China has huge inventories of both commercial and strategic oil, but we don't have any idea what they are.
Petroleum System Reserves and Investment Dynamics
The speaker analyses historical data showing how global oil reserves shifted upward after the 1970s shocks and again following the 2008 financial crisis. A detailed system diagram is presented to illustrate how production, sales revenue, and reinvestment form a reinforcing loop that sustains the industry despite price volatility. The analysis concludes that oil fields and their reserves act as the primary stock determining the system, while benchmark prices differ significantly from internal capital flows.
00:29:21 SPEAKER_011: Most countries have them and don't report them.
00:29:24 SPEAKER_011: So the U.S. does, Canada does, most of the OECD reports them; almost nobody else does.
00:29:31 SPEAKER_011: So, I happen to believe that trend is credible because I've looked at OECD data, and it doesn't drop off quite as sharply, but it does depart from the others.
00:29:44 SPEAKER_011: So, what does that mean?
00:29:45 SPEAKER_011: Well, if you zoom in a little bit and you look at the patterns of reserves, consumption, and production before about 1985, reserves were low.
00:30:01 SPEAKER_011: Consumption and production tracked.
00:30:03 SPEAKER_011: Okay, that was before the oil shocks, and so there's some text there that says "post oil shock shift."
00:30:12 SPEAKER_011: And so after the oil shocks of the 1970s and the early 1980s, you can see that reserves jumped up.
00:30:21 SPEAKER_011: Okay, the world kind of got the message that we can't take having spare capacity for granted, and so you go through something like twenty years or so—fifteen or twenty years—where everything is tracking pretty consistently,
00:30:43 SPEAKER_011: and then around the Great Financial Crisis in 2008–2009, then we see things change again.
00:30:51 SPEAKER_011: Reserves go way up.
00:30:53 SPEAKER_011: And this is a little subtle, but I think it's important.
00:30:58 SPEAKER_011: If you look at the pre-Great Financial Crisis trends, consumption and production track.
00:31:08 SPEAKER_011: Consumption was lower than production before the oil shocks.
00:31:11 SPEAKER_011: They were right on top of each other between the oil shocks and the Great Financial Crisis.
00:31:20 SPEAKER_011: consumption exceeded production.
00:31:22 SPEAKER_011: Okay, so again, I'm not ready to interpret that; I'm just telling you that's the pattern I see.
00:31:28 SPEAKER_011: And then, obviously, after 2014 to 2016, inventories drop off.
00:31:35 SPEAKER_011: And one interpretation of that would be, well, with shale, people thought, "Well, we got more oil than we can possibly use for you know to the end of time," or whatever the popular narrative was.
00:31:46 SPEAKER_011: And if we don't drill a shale well, it doesn't take very long compared to, say, trying to make a big discovery in deep water.
00:31:57 SPEAKER_011: So, for whatever reason, there's less concern about inventories in the last ten or twelve years.
00:32:06 SPEAKER_011: So, the conclusion that I come to from looking at this is that the system perpetuates itself despite very large variations in price, and the next chart shows that even more emphatically.
00:32:22 SPEAKER_011: So here it's the same data; I've just compressed the scaling because I've also put Brent price on the same axis, and so you can see that price goes all over the place,
00:32:36 SPEAKER_011: and the system just keeps on chugging forward with a few variations.
00:32:42 SPEAKER_011: So the final data slide then is the next one, and here what I'm showing is hardly a complete system diagram, but a more detailed explanation or mapping, I guess you would say,
00:33:04 SPEAKER_011: of how things work.
00:33:06 SPEAKER_011: And so on the left, you have the same stock we talked about before: oil fields and their reserves.
00:33:12 SPEAKER_011: We produce them through the flow into the next valve, which is sales, that generates revenue, which goes down into a capital stock for oil exploration and production.
00:33:27 SPEAKER_011: Some of that goes back into maintenance and investment, and that becomes a kind of a reinforcing loop.
00:33:36 SPEAKER_011: The sales go on into transport and storage: pipelines, tankers, inventories, etc., and out the other end come sales, which go back into a capital stock, some of which then goes back into maintenance and reinvestment.
00:33:56 SPEAKER_011: The sales go on to the only real buyer of crude oil that I know of, and that's refineries.
00:34:04 SPEAKER_011: And refineries produce fuels; they produce fuels, feedstocks for all kinds of things, including plastics and fertilizers and whatnot.
00:34:14 SPEAKER_011: And those go out the other end to sales.
00:34:18 SPEAKER_011: Again, some of that feeds into a capital stock, which then some of it goes back into investment, and then just kind of on the right-hand side, I've got economy.
00:34:29 SPEAKER_011: That's where it all leads.
00:34:31 SPEAKER_011: So, the conclusions that I reach are that the petroleum system is about oil fields and their reserves as the primary determinants, or the primary stock.
00:34:52 SPEAKER_011: Certainly, production draws down those reserves.
00:34:56 SPEAKER_011: Sales generate revenue for investment in the various boxes along the way.
00:35:03 SPEAKER_011: Refineries are the main buyers of oil.
00:35:07 SPEAKER_011: The benchmark prices that analysts follow are very different than the prices that come out of all of those stocks, as sales and into capital.
Petroleum System Dynamics Beyond Price Signals
The speaker argues that investment decisions rely on discounted future prices rather than current market rates due to long development timelines. This perspective suggests that production volume is a flow variable within a complex system where components interact dynamically. The discussion concludes by emphasizing that the petroleum system encompasses more than just price or supply metrics.
00:35:19 SPEAKER_011: And so, for instance, if you're talking about oil fields and reserves, okay, the price of oil today, let's just say, is ninety-five dollars.
00:35:28 SPEAKER_011: I don't know if it is or not, but let's just say it is, okay.
00:35:31 SPEAKER_011: And so, people say, "Oh, well, at ninety-five dollars, we're going to see a big jump in investment in oil exploration and production."
00:35:41 SPEAKER_011: Well, not so fast, because the people that make that decision aren't looking at today's price.
00:35:47 SPEAKER_011: They're looking at what will the price be after I make the capital investments?
00:35:53 SPEAKER_011: What will the price be when those investments result in wells and oil flows?
00:35:59 SPEAKER_011: And so, if we're talking about shale, we're talking about maybe twenty-four months from now.
00:36:05 SPEAKER_011: If we're talking about bigger, more conventional fields, we might be talking about five years, six years, seven years.
00:36:14 SPEAKER_011: So they're going to look at futures curves,
00:36:16 SPEAKER_011: and the prices that are going to be the basis of those investments are not only different than the price that people see on their screen or in their newspaper; they're going to be deeply discounted.
00:36:31 SPEAKER_011: And so, just for instance: if today oil price is ninety-five dollars, one year from now it's seventy-five.
00:36:40 SPEAKER_011: In two years from now, it's probably sixty.
00:36:42 SPEAKER_011: In three years from now, it's lower.
00:36:45 SPEAKER_011: And so the price factor that the petroleum system works off of is very different from whatever the price is today.
00:36:57 SPEAKER_011: So I don't want to give the impression that price doesn't matter because it does.
00:37:03 SPEAKER_011: I'm simply saying that the petroleum system is not organised around price, and that from a system's perspective, you could say that price is actually an emergent property of the petroleum system.
00:37:20 SPEAKER_011: Now, for those of us that have been engaged in peak oil for a while, and I've been a part of it now for probably 25 years, we focus on production or supply,
00:37:36 SPEAKER_011: and remember where we started in this conversation.
00:37:39 SPEAKER_011: Petroleum production is important, just like price is, but it's not a state-defining variable.
00:37:47 SPEAKER_011: It's a flow, and so part of the reason, maybe, that peak oil did not do a very good job, in my opinion, of predicting either the peak or when scarcity would really kick in,
00:38:04 SPEAKER_011: is because it's not the right variable in isolation.
00:38:10 SPEAKER_011: I think that's what I take away from all these graphs: that everything affects everything else, and that goes back to you know what Russell Acuff said in the first slide:
00:38:23 SPEAKER_011: a system is never the sum of its parts; it's the product of their interactions.
00:38:28 SPEAKER_011: And so there was nothing wrong with the concept of peak oil.
00:38:33 SPEAKER_011: It's just that we focused only on one component of the petroleum system, and we didn't really ask ourselves: Is that a principal component or a secondary component?
00:38:50 SPEAKER_011: And more important, you know, how does it interact and feedback with the other components?
00:38:57 SPEAKER_011: And I don't have an answer for you.
00:39:00 SPEAKER_011: I'm glad you know to BS about it when I'm done here in five or six seconds.
00:39:05 SPEAKER_011: But my point is not necessarily that we've done anything wrong.
00:39:12 SPEAKER_011: It's just that we've taken I think kind of a narrow view.
00:39:15 SPEAKER_011: And so I'll leave you then the very last slide that is Donella Meadows, and it says the petroleum system is bigger than price or supply, and I love this quote of hers.
00:39:29 SPEAKER_011: Whenever anyone says A causes B, I always ask, "How does B come back around to influence A?"
00:39:37 SPEAKER_011: So that is what I have to share with you today.
00:39:41 SPEAKER_011: It is still a work in progress.
00:39:46 SPEAKER_011: I would be disingenuous if I told you I know what it means.
00:39:51 SPEAKER_011: I've told you some of what I think.
00:39:54 SPEAKER_011: Just some of what I think it implies, but I'm still, I'm still researching and learning.
00:40:00 SPEAKER_011: And in fact, I just did a post on asking the same question about the economy: what is the economy really?
00:40:07 SPEAKER_011: And that was a lot harder for me.
00:40:11 SPEAKER_011: This was hard, but the economy was even harder.
00:40:14 SPEAKER_011: And you could argue, well, that's because I'm a petroleum geologist and not an economist.
00:40:19 SPEAKER_011: And fair enough.
00:40:20 SPEAKER_011: But it's harder because it's also more complex.
00:40:25 SPEAKER_011: I'll leave it there.
00:40:26 SPEAKER_011: If you have any questions or comments or discussion, let's do it.
00:40:32 SPEAKER_011: Bravo, sir.
00:40:32 SPEAKER_011: Bravo.
00:40:34 SPEAKER_011: Thank you, Art.
00:40:36 SPEAKER_011: Any questions from the panel?
00:40:40 SPEAKER_002: I've got a bunch on YouTube also, and well, I know that I guess we have some disagreements on well with some of the other panelists about the reserves, but I'll let David Miller go ahead.
00:40:59 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, thank you, Andrew.
00:41:00 SPEAKER_002: And I've been watching on YouTube there on my computer, so I thought I'd join just because the second last slide.
00:41:08 SPEAKER_002: When when you show the amount going to the economy, hopefully it's not pretty.
Entropy Law Limits Energy Efficiency and Power
One participant explains that only about half of the energy from a barrel of oil converts into useful work because the rest is lost as heat. This process transforms free energy into stable bound energy like carbon dioxide and water, which cannot be easily reused for civilization. Consequently, data centres rely on fossil fuels instead of renewables because solar and wind lack sufficient reliable power.
00:41:15 SPEAKER_013: When you show the amount going to the economy, what percentage of that is the total energy that comes out of the ground?
00:41:22 SPEAKER_013: I'm here.
00:41:24 SPEAKER_013: I was reading about the energy trap, and I'm just wondering what Art's thoughts on that were.
00:41:28 SPEAKER_013: How much actually goes into actual work when you look at the barrel that comes out of the ground and is used in the economy?
00:41:35 SPEAKER_013: Okay.
00:41:36 SPEAKER_013: Yeah.
00:41:37 SPEAKER_013: Well, David.
00:41:38 SPEAKER_013: Um.
00:41:39 SPEAKER_011: That's a great question, and I'm just gonna wing it here.
00:41:45 SPEAKER_011: I'm in the waiting room of a Volkswagen dealer here in Houston, so I don't have all my resources, but that'll make it even maybe more interesting.
00:41:54 SPEAKER_011: I'm going to say about half, and when I say half, I mean half of what's sold, and when I say half,
00:42:05 SPEAKER_011: I mean the part that actually converts into not only final consumption but usable or useful energy, and this is a really important concept.
00:42:18 SPEAKER_011: In that, I think most of us have at least a vague idea or understanding of the first law of thermodynamics, which is that energy can't be created or destroyed.
00:42:36 SPEAKER_011: And the second law is what's called the entropy law.
00:42:40 SPEAKER_011: And whenever we talk about entropy, you know that raises a whole lot of confusion, red flags, and concerns, but because entropy is, you know, the way most people use it is a measure of disorder,
00:42:56 SPEAKER_011: or how you know, a low, a high entropy, or low entropy fuel.
00:43:02 SPEAKER_011: Let's say oil or solar is, you know, once it's used and converted into work, the outcome is waste and heat, okay?
00:43:18 SPEAKER_011: So I think the simplest way to think about entropy, the way I think about it, is it's the difference between free energy and what's called bound energy.
00:43:29 SPEAKER_011: And so we have a climate crisis, if you will, because we're taking mostly hydrocarbons and converting them into carbon dioxide and water.
00:43:41 SPEAKER_011: Now carbon dioxide is bound energy.
00:43:45 SPEAKER_011: It's got plenty of energy in it.
00:43:47 SPEAKER_011: We just can't use it, and it's incredibly stable.
00:43:50 SPEAKER_011: I mean, you cannot just sit around and wait for carbon dioxide to leave the atmosphere.
00:43:56 SPEAKER_011: It can only be removed by being absorbed into natural sinks, and that takes a lot of time.
00:44:04 SPEAKER_011: Water is also an incredibly stable compound, and so the energy is still there.
00:44:12 SPEAKER_011: It's just bound, and it's not useful to us.
00:44:14 SPEAKER_011: So, back to your question: the amount of energy that comes out of the ground as oil, condensate, and is then converted into fuels,
00:44:26 SPEAKER_011: an awful lot of that is lost along the way as heat or waste.
00:44:33 SPEAKER_011: And so, you know, somebody will correct me because I'm probably wrong, but I don't think I'm too far from wrong in saying that probably only half of it is useful.
00:44:43 SPEAKER_011: Now, is that true also for other forms of energy?
00:44:50 SPEAKER_011: Let's say renewable energy, and the answer is yes, but it's not as extreme, and that's because we are going.
00:45:01 SPEAKER_011: In the case of solar, we're going directly to electricity from solar energy.
00:45:07 SPEAKER_011: We're not having to take natural gas or oil and burn it and run a turbine and you know all those kind of things.
00:45:14 SPEAKER_011: And so you could think of it as being a more efficient process.
00:45:20 SPEAKER_011: The problem that you have is that solar and wind are not particularly reliable and do not produce a lot of power.
00:45:30 SPEAKER_011: They produce a lot of energy, but not a lot of power.
00:45:33 SPEAKER_011: So power is energy per unit time, and that's what civilization values the most is power, and to finish this rather lengthy answer to what seems like a simple question, and it's not,
00:45:49 SPEAKER_011: and I know you know it's not, David, is that maximum power is generated not at maximum efficiency; it's generated at about forty-five percent efficiency.
00:46:02 SPEAKER_011: So when I want to get my car fixed here, and I want to speed home, I'm going to get a ton of power out of that car,
00:46:10 SPEAKER_011: and it's not going to be very efficient because I want to get home and eat.
00:46:13 SPEAKER_011: I've been away from home a long time.
00:46:15 SPEAKER_011: We value power in our civilization, and I think one of the tells is that in all the push for data centres, nobody's using renewable energy because it doesn't have any power.
00:46:30 SPEAKER_011: Okay, they're talking about natural gas, coal, and nuclear.
00:46:35 SPEAKER_011: So I don't want to get you know down that rabbit hole too far.
00:46:39 SPEAKER_011: But the point is, is that whatever form of energy you're using, you're going to lose energy when you convert it into work because that's just the way the entropy law works.
00:46:51 SPEAKER_011: Okay.
00:46:51 SPEAKER_011: Thanks.
00:46:52 SPEAKER_013: Yeah, I tell you, you could go down that rabbit hole for hours and hours.
00:46:56 SPEAKER_013: So yeah, I appreciate the answer.
00:46:57 SPEAKER_013: Thank you.
00:46:58 SPEAKER_013: Hey, I have a question.
00:47:00 SPEAKER_013: This is John.
00:47:03 SPEAKER_013: Go ahead.
00:47:04 SPEAKER_013: Hey, hey, Art, John Day.
00:47:06 SPEAKER_013: Hey, John, how you doing?
Renewables as Marginal Diversity Source
The discussion examines how wind and solar energy serve as important diversity sources at the margins rather than primary power sources. Speakers note that transmission losses and environmental impacts reduce the net efficiency of these intermittent renewable technologies. One participant clarifies that while renewables will not replace other sources entirely, they provide valuable backup power during grid failures.
00:47:08 SPEAKER_014: As we go further down the decades, and we're using up that high power fossil fuels, do you anticipate that it would still remain 50% when you get to doing the actual work of the economy?
00:47:24 SPEAKER_011: Well, again, the question was how much gets delivered to the economy.
00:47:30 SPEAKER_011: Okay, you're talking about something a little bit different, which is you know what does it actually take to power the economy, and that is a very important and valid question.
00:47:44 SPEAKER_011: But I think probably we want to let me answer let me answer what I think you're asking.
00:47:51 SPEAKER_011: What I think you're asking is that as energy gets more expensive and its quality is lower.
00:48:02 SPEAKER_011: In other words, the actual you know energy content or energy density is lower.
00:48:08 SPEAKER_011: It's going to take more delivered to the economy to do the same work.
00:48:14 SPEAKER_011: Am I interpreting your question right, John?
00:48:16 SPEAKER_011: Yeah, that was the question I asked.
00:48:18 SPEAKER_011: Thanks.
00:48:19 SPEAKER_011: Okay.
00:48:19 SPEAKER_011: Okay, sure.
00:48:24 SPEAKER_011: Barbara, you have your hand up.
00:48:27 SPEAKER_011: Did you have a question?
00:48:29 SPEAKER_011: Yeah, I've been listening on YouTube, but came back in because I want to make a different point about wind and solar, and that is they are seldom produced, particularly wind,
00:48:46 SPEAKER_011: anywhere near they need to be consumed.
00:48:49 SPEAKER_011: So not only are we destroying environments right and left by transmission lines and large infrastructure, but we're also losing a tremendous amount by transmission.
00:49:07 SPEAKER_015: So you know, I've got solar panels at the house, and I use them.
00:49:13 SPEAKER_015: They do a pretty decent job of what they do, but they're so intermittent.
00:49:18 SPEAKER_015: I couldn't possibly have enough batteries to keep the house running.
00:49:25 SPEAKER_015: So.
00:49:25 SPEAKER_015: I think you know they're not as reliable, but more importantly, they're the loss with the transmission, and the environmental problems with the transmission are just huge,
00:49:40 SPEAKER_015: and I think they're not nearly as good a deal as a lot of people think.
00:49:45 SPEAKER_011: Well, let me make a point and that's I appreciate the you know your personal experience with that, but a systems observation, Barbara, is that systems value diversity,
00:50:02 SPEAKER_011: and so I think that the expansion of renewables is completely consistent with the fact that the energy system.
00:50:13 SPEAKER_011: I'm not talking about the petroleum system now.
00:50:15 SPEAKER_011: I'm talking about the whole energy system.
00:50:17 SPEAKER_011: The energy system is expanding in the same way that the petroleum system is, and one of the ways in nature, so you know,
00:50:29 SPEAKER_011: a lot of the systems where it came out of the biological sciences, one of the ways that nature sort of buys insurance on its own survival is with diversity.
00:50:42 SPEAKER_011: That you know, biodiversity is a very important survival strategy.
00:50:48 SPEAKER_011: Now, it's not a very efficient one because it adds a lot of complexity.
00:50:52 SPEAKER_011: So, so where I would come down on renewables from a systems perspective is that they are an important bet on the future at the margins.
00:51:05 SPEAKER_011: Okay, that renewables will unlikely be a primary source of society's power in the near term, but they are increasingly becoming an important diversity source at the margin, and systems do that.
00:51:25 SPEAKER_011: All systems do that, and I think we should, you know, give them their due for contributing what they can.
00:51:34 SPEAKER_011: Oh, a hundred percent agree.
00:51:36 SPEAKER_015: And you know, I said I have solar, and it's exactly that reason.
00:51:40 SPEAKER_015: Our power companies are notoriously unreliable, and so having that alternate backup is really nice when it's 20 below in the winter,
00:51:54 SPEAKER_015: and I know I can run my furnace regardless of what's happening with the grid.
00:51:59 SPEAKER_015: Right.
00:51:59 SPEAKER_015: Right.
00:52:00 SPEAKER_015: So absolutely for diversity, not as a primary energy source, and certainly your efficiency.
00:52:06 SPEAKER_015: Yeah, that.
00:52:07 SPEAKER_015: I mean, that's what we're saying.
00:52:08 SPEAKER_015: We're saying the same thing.
00:52:11 SPEAKER_015: It's just not going to replace other sources as a hundred percent.
00:52:18 SPEAKER_002: So I just wanted to mention some related statistics that of the oil that we produce, about 19% is used up in production and refining, so 80% of it gets to an end user.
00:52:36 SPEAKER_002: Though technically all of it is used by the economy in one shape or another, and for solar.
00:52:42 SPEAKER_002: Well, it's 14% is used up in inverters and things like that, and about 2% is lost, two to five percent in distribution.
00:52:55 SPEAKER_002: Dan had his hand up.
00:52:56 SPEAKER_002: Okay, Dan, you go ahead.
00:52:58 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, yeah, sure.
00:52:59 SPEAKER_002: Barb, if I'm gonna stick my nose in this, so just repeat this.
Grid Complexity And Local Energy Solutions
A grid designer explains that increasing device count from coal plants to wind turbines creates instability rather than solving intermittency issues. The speaker proposes removing towns from the main grid to build local, stable power systems controlled by town councils instead of distant corporations. Another participant notes that electricity represents only twenty percent of energy needs while steel, concrete, and fertilizer still rely heavily on fossil fuels.
00:53:03 SPEAKER_016: I don't like beating my own drum, but I'm the guy that designed the computer system that controls the power grid for 26 states and parts of Canada.
00:53:10 SPEAKER_016: So the biggest issue I have to deal with daily.
00:53:11 SPEAKER_016: I have to deal on a daily basis with the power grid.
00:53:16 SPEAKER_016: Has to do with complexity.
00:53:18 SPEAKER_016: Let me give an example.
00:53:20 SPEAKER_016: Let's say you took a coal-fired power plant, and let's say you know, say a 100 megawatt power plant.
00:53:26 SPEAKER_016: Let's say you replaced it with 40 wind turbines.
00:53:29 SPEAKER_016: Well, by doing that, you've added, you went from a one device generating 100 megawatts that consumed one node on network, increased it by now it's 40 devices.
00:53:39 SPEAKER_016: Well, by increasing the complexity of the power grid, you made it unstable.
00:53:42 SPEAKER_016: So, one of the things I have a hard time trying to explain people is that whenever you go to ISO, whether you're going to add an AI data centre, which loads the power grid,
00:53:52 SPEAKER_016: or you're going to try to add generating capacity like a wind farm, there's a good chance that your ISO, after we do our modelling, we're just going to simply turn you down.
00:54:01 SPEAKER_016: And the reason why is due to complexity.
00:54:04 SPEAKER_016: So complexity is the biggest issue, and understand that that goes back to what's called the brass paradox, which is Grass paradox, which is named after Dietrich Graß, a mathematician.
00:54:13 SPEAKER_016: A sister law to that is Murphy's law: anything that can go wrong will go wrong.
00:54:18 SPEAKER_016: The more complex the system is, more chance it has of going wrong.
00:54:21 SPEAKER_016: So I understand exactly what you're talking about, Barbara.
00:54:23 SPEAKER_016: Our power grid is becoming more and more unstable, and we're getting to the point where we can't add capacity or subdivisions onto the system because of the instability.
00:54:35 SPEAKER_016: There are ways of solving that issue, but a lot of people don't like my answers, so.
00:54:41 SPEAKER_016: Oh yeah.
00:54:42 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, and it's not intermittence.
00:54:44 SPEAKER_016: I think I really want to.
00:54:45 SPEAKER_016: You know, I complain about intermittent, but it's not that.
00:54:49 SPEAKER_016: And by the way, why, Art, there are some AI data centres out west that are using geothermal, so they are switching over to that option.
00:54:58 SPEAKER_016: But if you look at it from a different background.
00:55:04 SPEAKER_016: Understand, most of my family's nuclear navy, and I came out of running coal-fired power plants for public utilities.
00:55:10 SPEAKER_016: Got into gas turbines, converting plants over to combined cycle.
00:55:14 SPEAKER_016: But I came to the point where, based on cost, base load, I mean, I can build more geothermal capacity than any other type of generation in the country,
00:55:22 SPEAKER_016: and solve a lot of problems by doing that.
00:55:24 SPEAKER_016: But like I said, what that means is I'm not adding capacity to the existing three power grids.
00:55:30 SPEAKER_016: I'm actually going to do something like take towns off the power grid and make the power grid even more stable by removing capacity, removing load and generation off of it.
00:55:40 SPEAKER_016: So, but until they come to that point, to that realization, we're all going to have to suffer through that.
00:55:46 SPEAKER_016: So that's and we're talking local solutions, yeah, rather than a thousand mile distribution.
00:55:56 SPEAKER_016: Understand, understand.
00:55:57 SPEAKER_016: Public utilities: the regulations go local, like your town, then it goes state, and then it goes federal.
00:56:03 SPEAKER_016: It's a lot easier for me to go to the mayor of a town, take your town off the power grid, build a power plant, and your town controls it.
00:56:10 SPEAKER_016: The employees working live in your town.
00:56:13 SPEAKER_016: You can go to the town council, complain at the mayor.
00:56:16 SPEAKER_016: You get satisfaction right there locally, rather than dealing with like Duke Energy, which is three or four states away, and a corporation that's so huge you're just a little ant in this giant system.
00:56:28 SPEAKER_016: You don't really make that much of a difference.
00:56:30 SPEAKER_016: And the other aspect you got to remember is.
00:56:31 SPEAKER_016: Aspect you've got to remember is we have these, and I'm guilty of doing this.
00:56:35 SPEAKER_016: I helped build all these energy markets that we use, and unfortunately, we've been infected by the Wall Streeters, and they basically gamble with electricity futures on the market.
00:56:45 SPEAKER_016: And there's no incentive to build generation.
00:56:47 SPEAKER_016: Just to understand that there's no incentive to build generation.
00:56:51 SPEAKER_016: There's only incentives to run power plants into the ground, and that's one of my biggest battles.
00:56:56 SPEAKER_016: Reason why I came to this meeting late is because I was in a meeting with a bunch of executives,
00:57:02 SPEAKER_016: because they won't do maintenance that they're supposed to do on their transmission systems and power plants, and that's sad, but it's true.
00:57:11 SPEAKER_016: Art, I think you had.
00:57:12 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, right.
00:57:14 SPEAKER_011: Just for perspective here, you know, electricity is 20% of our energy budget, and so we're focusing a lot on electricity, but the other 80% is what we are not talking about, and electric,
00:57:34 SPEAKER_011: and so by definition, you know, transport, extraction, industry, none of that, at least today, is running on electricity, much less renewables.
00:57:48 SPEAKER_011: And so that's you know, that that that's the elephant in the room.
00:57:51 SPEAKER_011: That I, I, you know, I can't remember how many times I've reminded people that.
00:57:58 SPEAKER_011: You know, Vasily Shmelev's famous four pillars of civilization are steel, concrete, plastic, and fertilizer or ammonia.
00:58:10 SPEAKER_011: And none of those are possible mostly without coal, but certainly without natural gas.
00:58:19 SPEAKER_011: The plastic and the fertilizer we only, we only can get plastic from oil, from naphtha.
00:58:26 SPEAKER_011: From naphtha and natural gas, and most of the fertilizer comes from natural gas.
00:58:32 SPEAKER_011: And so, you know, as far as getting back to systems, what does the system need to support the activities, the social and economic activities of society?
00:58:47 SPEAKER_011: It needs a heck of a lot of fossil fuels, and the idea that we can substitute other forms of energy for fossil fuels.
00:59:00 SPEAKER_011: You know, maybe someday we'll be able to.
Oil Financialization Drives Price Volatility
One participant argues that nominal price volatility in the late 1980s and early 1990s resulted from oil becoming a financialized commodity rather than running out of supply. The discussion explains that once energy entered the global casino, factors beyond simple supply and demand began to influence market prices significantly. Entities must hedge prices because future drilling outcomes remain uncertain.
00:59:02 SPEAKER_011: But I mean, most people.
00:59:03 SPEAKER_011: And next time you're out walking around, I mean, look at the sidewalk, look at what it's made of, and what you'll see if it's broken somewhere is it's got big chunks of rock in it.
00:59:14 SPEAKER_011: It is an eighteen hundred degree Celsius process to create concrete, and all of the extraction of the clay and the action of the clay and the sand and the gravel is done by diesel,
00:59:27 SPEAKER_011: and if we don't have concrete, we're not building anything.
00:59:31 SPEAKER_011: Steel, I mean, smelters again, very high temperature processes.
00:59:36 SPEAKER_011: Yeah, we could use electric arc furnaces to some extent.
00:59:40 SPEAKER_011: Yeah, we could recycle a little bit of steel, but by and large, we are locked in to not only fossil fuels but coal for the things that keep our civilization running,
00:59:54 SPEAKER_011: and systems are not particularly sensitive to things like values and morality.
01:00:02 SPEAKER_011: So you know, we can complain about them a lot, but they are, they kind of have a life of their own, and that you know,
01:00:11 SPEAKER_011: that's a point that Meadows and Acuff and you know there's a dozen or so other systems pioneers that I think very highly of.
01:00:21 SPEAKER_011: They're all going to tell you the same thing.
01:00:23 SPEAKER_011: These are what they you know call them self-organising systems or complex adaptive.
01:00:29 SPEAKER_011: Call them whatever you like.
01:00:30 SPEAKER_011: Once they get going, or call it the superorganism if you like, Nate Hagens or Kerry King.
01:00:36 SPEAKER_011: But they're going to do what they do regardless of what we think, and our big ideas about how to change them usually don't consider what the feedbacks are going to be as a result.
01:00:49 SPEAKER_011: of that intervention.
01:00:52 SPEAKER_016: Yep, I'm going to interject here, Art, just a second,
01:00:56 SPEAKER_016: so people understand that you know because I deal with a couple refineries and what they're looking at globally is the planet we refine something like twenty-eight point two to twenty-eight point three million barrels of
01:01:08 SPEAKER_016: diesel per day,
01:01:09 SPEAKER_016: but the I'm sorry, that's the consumption, but the production is only twenty-seven point two, so we're pulling you know a million barrels a day out of stock, and nobody knows how deep the stock is,
01:01:21 SPEAKER_016: right?
01:01:22 SPEAKER_016: So that's a huge question.
01:01:23 SPEAKER_016: I give credit to Art Berman, basically identifying that the diesel is a very important part.
01:01:30 SPEAKER_016: You know that we have to pay attention on our society.
01:01:33 SPEAKER_016: And Art, by the way, the steel guys—they switched over to using refinery coke a long time ago because we don't have enough pure, pure enough coal for making steel anymore.
01:01:44 SPEAKER_016: So that was probably a good fifteen, twenty years ago, and as far as all the coal fired power plants I converted, the reason why we did it is because of the quality of the coal.
01:01:53 SPEAKER_016: We just don't have it here in America.
01:01:55 SPEAKER_016: There may be other parts in the world that have high quality coal, but we just we just don't have it anymore.
01:02:01 SPEAKER_016: So, thank you, sir, for identifying that.
01:02:03 SPEAKER_016: That's a difficult thing.
01:02:04 SPEAKER_016: Ivor, you've had your hand up for a while.
01:02:07 SPEAKER_016: Ivor, did you want to ask?
01:02:08 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, I was wondering.
01:02:10 SPEAKER_004: Somewhere, you know, you have your picture of the Brent price, kind of going wonky.
01:02:15 SPEAKER_004: It really starts going up and down at a certain point, and I've heard I've heard this theory that you know toward the end of a resource,
01:02:23 SPEAKER_004: all of a sudden you have these big swings up, down, up, down, up, down.
01:02:29 SPEAKER_004: And I was wondering, yeah, right there where the Brent price takes off around two thousand and around two thousand five.
01:02:36 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, I was wondering, what does that signify,
01:02:40 SPEAKER_004: and is there a way that the you know our capitalist system can you know I mean we're we're we're continuing to chug along but is it going to you know is it a sign that
01:02:50 SPEAKER_004: something's wrong?
01:02:53 SPEAKER_011: Okay, well I assume that's directed at me, so I'm not going to raise my hand.
01:02:57 SPEAKER_011: So those are those are nominal prices.
01:02:59 SPEAKER_011: If I if I showed them as you know real prices, 2026 prices, the past would look a lot more like the present than it does, but in answer to your question,
01:03:15 SPEAKER_011: we are not running out of oil.
01:03:20 SPEAKER_011: We are not anywhere close to running out of oil.
01:03:22 SPEAKER_011: And as Colin Campbell and John Laherrere pointed out, which most peak oil people ignored at the time and ignore today, the issue isn't how much oil we have; it's how much cheap oil we have.
01:03:38 SPEAKER_011: So that's one factor.
01:03:40 SPEAKER_011: The other factor that's important here, Ivor, is that oil was not a financialized commodity until the late 1980s, early 1990s, and that's really what you're seeing.
01:03:55 SPEAKER_011: Once, once oil became part of our our financial, you know, global casino, it became a lot more subject to factors beyond supply and demand.
01:04:09 SPEAKER_011: Now, unlike many people, I'm not.
01:04:12 SPEAKER_011: I don't.
01:04:12 SPEAKER_011: I don't think that's a problem.
01:04:13 SPEAKER_011: I don't think that's.
01:04:15 SPEAKER_011: Well, I try to stay neutral on everything.
01:04:18 SPEAKER_011: I'm neither an optimist nor a pessimist.
01:04:20 SPEAKER_011: I just try to look at the data.
01:04:22 SPEAKER_011: But I see that you know, having more of a financial footprint on energy is kind of what the system does.
01:04:32 SPEAKER_011: The you know, that's that.
01:04:33 SPEAKER_011: That's part of the way that things can be.
01:04:36 SPEAKER_011: You know, better, better integrated and managed at the very least.
01:04:44 SPEAKER_011: It's, I mean, an awful lot of, you know, the entities in my systems diagram.
01:04:51 SPEAKER_011: They have to hedge their prices because they don't know what they're going to be when they drill their wells and build their refineries.
01:04:59 SPEAKER_011: And just a final comment then about Dan.
Global Conventional Oil Production Limits
One participant explains that global conventional oil production peaked around 2005, forcing reliance on non-conventional sources which drove prices higher. Another speaker argues that blaming oil companies for climate change is unproductive and suggests the petroleum system is larger than price fluctuations imply. The discussion also addresses a pre-existing deficit in diesel refinery capacity that predates recent geopolitical conflicts.
01:05:01 SPEAKER_011: You know, we have a deficit in diesel refinery capacity in the world that existed before the Iran War and before the Ukraine War, and you know the reason for that,
01:05:18 SPEAKER_011: and we hear an awful lot about underinvestment, underinvestment.
01:05:22 SPEAKER_011: You know, we haven't been making the same investments in exploration and production.
01:05:28 SPEAKER_011: Well, you know, underinvestment is a value judgment.
01:05:31 SPEAKER_011: Underinvestment from whose perspective?
01:05:32 SPEAKER_011: Well.
01:05:33 SPEAKER_011: Oil companies, refining companies, solar companies—these are not public service companies.
01:05:40 SPEAKER_011: Okay, they're not in the business of being philanthropic organisations to society's needs.
01:05:48 SPEAKER_011: They are in the business of making a profit for their shareholders.
01:05:53 SPEAKER_011: And when you have an investment environment which says, "Oh, oil is toast," it's history.
01:06:02 SPEAKER_011: You know.
01:06:03 SPEAKER_011: We're going to be running on solar panels, and you know, and batteries, and God knows what.
01:06:09 SPEAKER_011: Peak demand, you know.
01:06:11 SPEAKER_011: Guess what?
01:06:11 SPEAKER_011: Nobody wants to invest in long-term enterprises like refineries, nor should they.
01:06:19 SPEAKER_011: Okay, so you know, so if you want to just stop oil, and there are people who think that's a good idea, and I try to stay neutral.
01:06:27 SPEAKER_011: I think it's a dumb idea, but it would be good for the environment.
01:06:31 SPEAKER_011: It would be terrible for civilization, but nonetheless, I mean, I think we, you know, we have to.
01:06:39 SPEAKER_011: I like to get away from blaming people.
01:06:42 SPEAKER_011: You know, it's not the oil companies' fault that we have climate change.
01:06:47 SPEAKER_011: It's our fault for consuming oil and for bitching when we don't have it available.
01:06:53 SPEAKER_011: I'm not saying the oil companies are, you know, paragons of virtue because they're not, but.
01:07:00 SPEAKER_011: You know, I think it's it's it's it's not very productive to blame the way things are on some member of the system or some member of society.
01:07:11 SPEAKER_011: I think it's better to try to understand the state of things today and how we got here, and we can worry about the morality, the value judgment, and the future predictions after we get there.
01:07:26 SPEAKER_011: And the point of this presentation and the point of my research is was to tell myself I've been in the oil business for 48 years and I had a hard time drawing those diagrams because
01:07:41 SPEAKER_011: I didn't understand the petroleum system very well and I probably understand it a lot better than 99.9 percent of the people on the planet.
01:07:49 SPEAKER_011: So you know this is where we need to start with all of the problem.
01:07:56 SPEAKER_011: The problems and the crises that face our civilization is not with whose fault is it and what solutions can we find.
01:08:05 SPEAKER_011: It's let's understand what's happening and how we got here, and then we might be ready to start doing things.
01:08:12 SPEAKER_011: I hope we don't blame first, but at least you know, at least if there are solutions to be had, let's face them on understanding.
01:08:23 SPEAKER_002: So Roger hasn't spoken yet, and you have your hand up.
01:08:27 SPEAKER_002: Roger, are you able to unmute and speak?
01:08:30 SPEAKER_002: Yes, Andrew, can you hear me?
01:08:33 SPEAKER_002: Yes, yes, we can.
01:08:34 SPEAKER_002: Go ahead.
01:08:38 SPEAKER_002: Hello, Roger.
01:08:40 SPEAKER_002: Andrew, can you hear me?
01:08:41 SPEAKER_002: Yes, yes.
01:08:43 SPEAKER_002: Oh, okay.
01:08:43 SPEAKER_002: I can't hear you, but I see the thumbs up.
01:08:46 SPEAKER_002: Okay.
01:08:47 SPEAKER_002: So, first of all, apologies.
01:08:50 SPEAKER_002: I came late, and I'm still trying to figure out the time difference.
01:08:54 SPEAKER_002: between you guys and us.
01:08:55 SPEAKER_019: I feel stupid, so I came in late.
01:08:58 SPEAKER_019: I greatly apologise about that to both you and Art.
01:09:02 SPEAKER_019: Talk, I'd love to have heard Art.
01:09:03 SPEAKER_019: I apologise about that.
01:09:08 SPEAKER_019: Andrew, you can—they can still hear me, can they?
01:09:11 SPEAKER_019: Yes.
01:09:12 SPEAKER_019: Thumbs up or no thumbs up?
01:09:14 SPEAKER_019: Can they hear me?
01:09:14 SPEAKER_019: Yes.
01:09:15 SPEAKER_019: Yes.
01:09:16 SPEAKER_019: Yes.
01:09:16 SPEAKER_019: They can hear you.
01:09:17 SPEAKER_019: One, two, three, four.
01:09:21 SPEAKER_019: I've lost everybody.
01:09:22 SPEAKER_019: Yes, we can hear you.
01:09:24 SPEAKER_019: One, two, three.
01:09:25 SPEAKER_019: I hope you can hear me.
01:09:26 SPEAKER_019: Anyway, our talk.
01:09:27 SPEAKER_019: I don't see any movement.
01:09:28 SPEAKER_019: I've lost my Wi-Fi or something.
01:09:30 SPEAKER_019: No, I'm on Wi-Fi.
01:09:31 SPEAKER_019: I don't understand.
01:09:32 SPEAKER_019: Anyway, Iva, I unfortunately clicked off this talk when after you asked your question.
01:09:38 SPEAKER_019: So I think Art might have answered it, but I hope you can hear me, you guys.
01:09:43 SPEAKER_019: So the one about why the oil price went up so high after two thousand and four, two thousand and five, is, as I think Art said,
01:09:53 SPEAKER_019: the world hit its resource limited maximum production of conventional oil.
01:10:00 SPEAKER_019: Why am I seeing no pictures at all?
01:10:03 SPEAKER_019: What am I doing wrong?
01:10:06 SPEAKER_019: Images, pictures.
01:10:08 SPEAKER_019: Anyway, let's do that and see if I can be seen.
01:10:12 SPEAKER_019: No, it's all disconnected.
01:10:14 SPEAKER_019: I'm sorry.
01:10:14 SPEAKER_019: Anyway, hit the reset to the maximum of conventional.
01:10:19 SPEAKER_019: Global conventional oil was almost limited. 2005 was the maximum, and it's been going down since 2008.
01:10:28 SPEAKER_019: So of course we're having to use all the non-conventionals and NGLs and non-conventionals combined, and that's what pushed the price up so heavily.
01:10:37 SPEAKER_019: There is an excellent paper, Charlie Hall et al.
01:10:42 SPEAKER_019: The paper is significant, under-recognized constraints to global oil supply, just published in Elsevier journal Energy, significant under-recognized constraints to global oil supply.
01:10:57 SPEAKER_019: It says all those things, and Art.
Resource Limits Versus Productive Capacity Issues
Speakers distinguish between resource scarcity and issues of productive capacity regarding oil development timelines. One participant argues that population growth should match environmental capacity rather than forcing expansion at all costs. The discussion concludes with advice to learn how to adapt to complex adaptive systems instead of trying to change them.
01:11:00 SPEAKER_019: It does say, don't blame the oil companies, don't blame us.
01:11:04 SPEAKER_019: It's just resource limits, and we're the people using the oil and the gas and all that.
01:11:08 SPEAKER_019: I hope you could hear me.
01:11:10 SPEAKER_019: I'm sorry.
01:11:11 SPEAKER_019: End of that.
01:11:13 SPEAKER_019: Bye bye.
01:11:14 SPEAKER_019: Yes.
01:11:14 SPEAKER_019: Okay, we can hear you.
01:11:15 SPEAKER_019: Thank you.
01:11:15 SPEAKER_002: Okay, do you want to respond to that?
01:11:19 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, just a semantic issue.
01:11:23 SPEAKER_002: It's not resources.
01:11:25 SPEAKER_002: It's immediately available supply.
01:11:29 SPEAKER_011: Okay, we have we have we have gobs and gobs of undiscovered resources.
01:11:35 SPEAKER_011: Gobs of proved reserves.
01:11:38 SPEAKER_011: The problem that happened in the early two thousands was we couldn't develop our fields fast enough,
01:11:44 SPEAKER_011: and so by the time it was taking a seven to ten or eleven years from discovery to first oil, and so by the time we actually got a new discovery online,
01:11:55 SPEAKER_011: old fields had become more depleted.
01:11:58 SPEAKER_011: So it wasn't it wasn't a resource scarcity; it was a productive capacity issue.
01:12:07 SPEAKER_011: But again, you know, I've been down this road before, and conventional oil only matters to peak oil people.
01:12:16 SPEAKER_011: I mean, refineries are the only people that buy oil in the world, and they couldn't give a crap whether the oil comes from the Bakken or you know Arab light.
01:12:26 SPEAKER_011: If it meets their specs, they'll buy, and if the price is right, they will buy it.
01:12:32 SPEAKER_011: Nobody cares whether it's conventional or unconventional oil, except for us, I guess.
01:12:39 SPEAKER_011: And I've gotten over it.
01:12:41 SPEAKER_011: I cared a lot originally, but so I don't think I disagree with Roger.
01:12:49 SPEAKER_011: I just think I disagree with the way Roger said it, and I'll just leave it there.
01:12:57 SPEAKER_011: All right.
01:12:57 SPEAKER_002: I think Barbara has had her hand up a long time, and then Dan.
01:13:01 SPEAKER_002: Barbara, go ahead.
01:13:03 SPEAKER_002: You know, I'm just going to do a quick comment on that.
01:13:05 SPEAKER_002: It's the cost of production of some of these non-conventionals.
01:13:08 SPEAKER_015: Unconventional that may be eating our lunch as well as the time from discovery to actually using them.
01:13:16 SPEAKER_015: But I actually raised my hand because it occurs to me that one of the things that we don't talk about is the fact that in most of the world now population growth is below replacement,
01:13:34 SPEAKER_015: and that should technically mean that we don't need growth in energy usage, and I'm thinking that one of the things that is probably eating our lunch is the growth at all possible costs,
01:13:51 SPEAKER_015: including killing ourselves with environmental degradation.
01:13:56 SPEAKER_015: Which would have been fine if we were growing a billion people every few years, but since we're not,
01:14:03 SPEAKER_015: perhaps we need to think more fully about what it would look like to match growth to population growth, rather than trying to force more people on the world when we know we're beyond capacity.
01:14:25 SPEAKER_002: Okay, did someone want the response to that?
01:14:28 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, I do.
01:14:29 SPEAKER_002: Okay, go ahead, Art.
01:14:31 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, nonsense.
01:14:32 SPEAKER_011: Systems don't care about any of that.
01:14:36 SPEAKER_011: The oil from shale is cheaper; the finding cost is cheaper than just about any conventional oil in the world.
01:14:47 SPEAKER_011: That's why everybody went to it.
01:14:49 SPEAKER_011: The fact that everything is more expensive is a problem.
01:14:54 SPEAKER_011: You know, we can disagree with the way things are and kind of you know, we can disagree in a way that sounds like we're blaming people, but you know, it's just not helpful,
01:15:12 SPEAKER_011: in my opinion, to make suggestions like you know we should stop growing because nobody's calling me to ask me my opinion about that.
01:15:22 SPEAKER_011: Nobody's calling the president of the United States.
01:15:25 SPEAKER_011: Not that he would know what to say.
01:15:27 SPEAKER_011: This is this is not up for a vote.
01:15:31 SPEAKER_011: This is this is what a complex adaptive system is doing, and it doesn't ask if we like it or not.
01:15:39 SPEAKER_011: We, our job, my job, as someone who tries to interpret the system to people who don't know quite as much as I do, is learn how to adapt.
01:15:55 SPEAKER_011: Stop trying to change it, and learn how to adapt.
01:15:59 SPEAKER_011: And I, you know, I mean, whatever aspect of this thing you like or you don't like, you know, Tolstoy famously said, you know, kings are slaves to history.
01:16:11 SPEAKER_011: Nobody really changes history very much.
01:16:15 SPEAKER_011: It's got a huge momentum to it.
01:16:19 SPEAKER_011: Doesn't mean you shouldn't try.
01:16:21 SPEAKER_011: Doesn't mean you shouldn't think about trying.
01:16:23 SPEAKER_011: But you need to understand that.
01:16:25 SPEAKER_011: I mean, this is the way things are.
01:16:30 SPEAKER_011: And my advice to people is learn how to adapt.
01:16:34 SPEAKER_011: And if adapt means you know to be more self-sufficient, to be more local, to be more psychologically sound, to be more spiritual—I mean, you know—you define what it means to adapt yourself.
01:16:49 SPEAKER_011: Nobody's, you know, I'm not going to tell you what to do, but I don't think that wishing that things were different is a very useful approach to things.
US Canada Refining Capacity and Diesel Supply Concerns
Speakers discuss how maintenance shutdowns of American refineries could cause diesel prices to rise even if crude oil prices fall. The conversation highlights that the United States imports heavy crude from Canada while Canada relies on US exports for refined products like gasoline and diesel. Participants emphasize the need for better cooperation between the two nations to manage these shared infrastructure challenges.
01:17:02 SPEAKER_011: Okay, Dan.
01:17:05 SPEAKER_011: Yeah, the thing I talked about diesel.
01:17:08 SPEAKER_016: What we're watching right now, we're all very concerned about the capacity that's over in Russia, right?
01:17:14 SPEAKER_016: Understand, this isn't anything that we've done here in America.
01:17:17 SPEAKER_016: The refiners we have here are doing the best they can.
01:17:20 SPEAKER_016: The capacity factors are ninety-four percent.
01:17:23 SPEAKER_016: In fact, a lot of us are actually quite afraid, and the reason why is because we're afraid that we shut some of these down to do maintenance.
01:17:30 SPEAKER_016: The prices are going to go up.
01:17:32 SPEAKER_016: Remember, diesel, gasoline; these are international products, sold in international markets.
01:17:37 SPEAKER_016: So we, you know, the industry has no control over the prices.
01:17:40 SPEAKER_016: And I can see a situation where we lose, we're losing enough refining capacity that crude oil prices could go down, but diesel prices go up simply because we don't have enough, enough refining capacity.
01:17:52 SPEAKER_016: And there really isn't anything that really happened here.
01:17:55 SPEAKER_016: You know, we can say woulda, shoulda, coulda.
01:17:57 SPEAKER_016: You know, I can point out maybe a Lyondell there in Houston or some things that happened in California.
01:18:02 SPEAKER_016: But the reality was is that there were some economic reasons why we shut those things down.
01:18:08 SPEAKER_016: Very big, complex machineries you have to do maintenance on.
01:18:12 SPEAKER_016: So we're afraid, like I said, if we don't, we got to shut them down.
01:18:14 SPEAKER_016: Do maintenance, prices go up.
01:18:16 SPEAKER_016: If we don't do maintenance, those places become even more dangerous.
01:18:19 SPEAKER_016: We have no control of it.
01:18:21 SPEAKER_016: As an example, right now Germany has seventy-five percent of their total reserves for natural gas, and we're looking out two or three years.
01:18:31 SPEAKER_016: We're not sure if we're going to have enough natural gas in the world to supply the world with natural gas.
01:18:37 SPEAKER_016: And the biggest reason is because what's going on with Qatar there in the Persian Gulf.
01:18:42 SPEAKER_016: You know, that wasn't anything we did, but we're all going to have to live through this.
01:18:46 SPEAKER_016: Now you say, Dan, what are we going to do?
01:18:48 SPEAKER_016: I said we're going to have to adapt.
01:18:50 SPEAKER_016: We're going to see these high prices not because we don't have enough oil, because we don't have enough capacity with our infrastructure, and we've got two wars that really need to end.
01:19:00 SPEAKER_016: And as far as some of the things that go on between the United States and Canada,
01:19:05 SPEAKER_016: we get about four or four and a half million barrels a day of some really heavy crude that makes really good diesel and jet fuel here in America.
01:19:12 SPEAKER_016: But everybody has to understand that Canada imports eighty percent of their refined products, diesel and gasoline, from the United States.
01:19:19 SPEAKER_016: It goes back and forth between the countries.
01:19:21 SPEAKER_016: Then we make it up with other countries.
01:19:23 SPEAKER_016: So what I'm trying to say is, we need to get along with our neighbours.
01:19:26 SPEAKER_016: We need to understand each other and talk, and not sit there point fingers at each other.
01:19:32 SPEAKER_016: And why we've got the situation going on between the United States that really needs to end.
01:19:40 SPEAKER_002: And I just got this chart that shows what Art was talking about.
01:19:45 SPEAKER_002: How the total production is increasing, even though the conventional production may have been decreasing, but we've got all these other ones like the natural gas liquids and the tight oil, which is the shale oil,
01:20:00 SPEAKER_002: and heavy, the extra heavy oil.
01:20:03 SPEAKER_002: All of those are kind of making up for the gap, at least at present.
01:20:08 SPEAKER_002: Okay, next, Iver.
01:20:14 SPEAKER_004: I mean, I agree with you, Art.
01:20:17 SPEAKER_004: That we really can't change the way things are, but I feel like you know, knowing what I know about climate change and what is going right now,
01:20:28 SPEAKER_004: I think we need to you know fight against the craziness of what is going on with our culture a little bit.
01:20:37 SPEAKER_004: I just feel like personally, I need to you know fight for survival of future people, but the thing is, I feel like well, this last Tuesday,
01:20:49 SPEAKER_004: I feel like you know I went out a lot and canvassed and talked to people, and maybe did a tiny part toward it, and I just feel like I'm sorry, I'm Swedish,
01:21:03 SPEAKER_004: I can't forget it, I can't stop fighting.
01:21:05 SPEAKER_004: Sorry.
01:21:09 SPEAKER_004: All right.
Limitations Of Emissions Reduction Strategies
One participant argues that reducing emissions alone cannot solve climate issues because atmospheric carbon dioxide remains stable for centuries after net zero is reached. Another speaker suggests a rural transition as a potential Plan C to address these challenges.
01:21:10 SPEAKER_004: Well, I don't know if that was a question, but it's an idea that the thing about it is we are freaking cooked.
01:21:20 SPEAKER_004: I mean, if we go over three degrees centigrade, this place is just cooked.
01:21:25 SPEAKER_004: And they're saying now that possibly by 2050, we might pass the three degrees.
01:21:33 SPEAKER_004: And if we pass the three degrees, I mean, desert planet.
01:21:38 SPEAKER_002: Well, Reichstead was saying that we have to discover a lot more in order for it to really become an issue, and our discoveries have been declining for so long that it doesn't seem likely.
01:21:52 SPEAKER_004: It'd be nice if it fixes itself, but we just blew right past one point five.
01:21:57 SPEAKER_004: We're headed to two, and it's not slowing down.
01:22:00 SPEAKER_011: Well, the discovery, yeah, and here's the thing that I think you have to understand, and that is that for as much as reducing emissions is what we should do, it is not a solution.
01:22:16 SPEAKER_011: It is absolutely not a solution.
01:22:19 SPEAKER_011: That I mean, if you look at the atmospheric concentrations we have right now, go back to what I said early on in the talk.
01:22:27 SPEAKER_011: Carbon dioxide is as stable as they come, and there's only one way to get it out of the atmosphere, and that is through natural sinks.
01:22:36 SPEAKER_011: And you know, so if you say we're—I think I took Shell.
01:22:43 SPEAKER_011: Shell's got a projection out to 2100 of all kinds of things, including oil and CO2, and it's a very optimistic projection from a climate perspective because it's got coal dropping off a cliff,
01:22:58 SPEAKER_011: it's got emissions going down, et cetera, et cetera.
01:23:01 SPEAKER_011: It's like you know the most optimistic I've seen from certainly from an oil company.
01:23:07 SPEAKER_011: I just, I just carried it out.
01:23:09 SPEAKER_011: I said, okay, let's let's track all of them and remember that reducing emissions is not zero emissions.
01:23:17 SPEAKER_011: And so I carried it out to the point of net zero, and I did a calculation which says that once we reach net zero,
01:23:29 SPEAKER_011: it will take on the order of 225 years for those concentrations to go back to 1990 levels, 225 years.
01:23:40 SPEAKER_011: Okay, so you know all the people that pound the table.
01:23:43 SPEAKER_011: Oh, you know we gotta you know we gotta stop using fossil fuels.
01:23:46 SPEAKER_011: We gotta start using more solar panels.
01:23:49 SPEAKER_011: Okay, fine, I get it.
01:23:51 SPEAKER_011: But and we do, but it really doesn't help except to slow the pain.
01:24:01 SPEAKER_011: I mean, we've got centuries of recovery in front of us, and I don't think many people understand that.
01:24:08 SPEAKER_011: And I'm not—I don't want to bum anybody out, but that is the reality, and that's why I say that you know all of the high-minded, moralistic,
01:24:18 SPEAKER_011: and even bleeding into blame—you know—I'm not going to change people's behaviour any more than I'm going to change the momentum of history.
01:24:28 SPEAKER_011: But to this group of people who wants to understand, who wants to learn, we need to understand first.
01:24:36 SPEAKER_011: We need to understand what we're up against, and what we're up against here isn't going to be fixed by solar panels and wind turbines.
01:24:43 SPEAKER_011: It's not that that's not that again that you know that that may be part of some kind of solution, but the honest truth is we don't have a clue what to do next.
01:24:57 SPEAKER_011: We don't have a clue, and I think that is an important realization to say you're right.
01:25:06 SPEAKER_011: We better understand this a whole lot better before we start jumping to solutions.
01:25:11 SPEAKER_011: I mean, we spent twenty trillion dollars on wind and solar over the last twenty years, and I'm not saying we shouldn't have.
01:25:18 SPEAKER_011: I'm saying it hadn't done us any good.
01:25:22 SPEAKER_011: You know that's not a very good investment.
01:25:24 SPEAKER_011: So that was Plan B, and Plan B doesn't work.
01:25:29 SPEAKER_011: What's Plan C?
01:25:30 SPEAKER_011: We don't have one, and so in order to have a plan, somebody, if you know, to play the blame game, you know,
01:25:38 SPEAKER_011: we should have looked at this before we did Plan B. What is the problem we're trying to solve?
01:25:44 SPEAKER_011: And somebody says, "Hey, what if we do wind and solar?"
01:25:46 SPEAKER_011: Well, let's run that scenario out.
01:25:48 SPEAKER_011: That's not going to solve it.
01:25:50 SPEAKER_011: Okay, well, let's keep it on the table and let's try.
01:25:52 SPEAKER_011: Let's look at a Plan C or a Plan B. We don't have any of those, and so again, I'm not—I don't want to be critical,
01:26:00 SPEAKER_011: and I certainly don't want to tell anyone that they shouldn't.
01:26:04 SPEAKER_011: You know, I mean, you know, Iver.
01:26:06 SPEAKER_011: I mean, you know, whether you're Swedish or not.
01:26:09 SPEAKER_011: I mean, you know, fight for what you think you should and what you think is important and valuable.
01:26:15 SPEAKER_011: You know, I voted Tuesday also.
01:26:17 SPEAKER_011: I've never given money to a political candidate in my life.
01:26:22 SPEAKER_011: I gave money to this Black guy in Mississippi.
01:26:26 SPEAKER_011: I gave money to this Latino.
01:26:27 SPEAKER_011: To this Latina woman, who's now the governor of Texas, first time in 76 years I've ever given money.
01:26:35 SPEAKER_011: Okay, so now you know where my sentiments are.
01:26:37 SPEAKER_011: But so I'm not saying you're wrong.
01:26:40 SPEAKER_011: I'm just saying that we need to understand the magnitude of what we're up against and stop trying to solve it until we understand it.
01:26:50 SPEAKER_011: And I'll shut up there.
01:26:54 SPEAKER_011: Thank you.
01:26:55 SPEAKER_011: I agree.
01:26:55 SPEAKER_011: I just scary.
01:26:56 SPEAKER_002: I just wanted to briefly say that well, at least I have a Plan C, but maybe not a lot of people like it.
01:27:02 SPEAKER_002: But you know, Simon has to run the numbers, and it can work, which is the rural transition.
Oil Reserves Versus Inventory Debate
Speakers discuss the discrepancy between government-reported oil reserves and actual company data, noting that undiscovered resources often lie in expensive locations. They suggest that rising extraction costs will cause energy prices to steadily increase over time. The conversation concludes by emphasizing adaptation to these economic shifts rather than attempting to fix an inherently complex system.
01:27:08 SPEAKER_002: But I know it's highly debated.
01:27:11 SPEAKER_002: Anyhow, you have to run the feedbacks on.
01:27:15 SPEAKER_002: You got to do the system.
01:27:16 SPEAKER_002: That's the problem.
01:27:17 SPEAKER_011: Yeah, well, it's a good idea, but I mean, nothing works in isolation.
01:27:21 SPEAKER_011: It all has to synchronize with the way the system is and what the expectations are, and that's you know I'm with you.
01:27:31 SPEAKER_011: I'm 100% with you, Andre.
01:27:32 SPEAKER_011: I'm not disagreeing with you.
01:27:34 SPEAKER_011: I'm just saying that history tells us that we try to fix something without understanding it.
01:27:41 SPEAKER_011: We usually make it worse.
01:27:42 SPEAKER_011: Yeah, yeah.
01:27:43 SPEAKER_002: I'd like to clarify that it's not about fixing it.
01:27:46 SPEAKER_002: It's about how do we keep people alive with the depleting fossil reserves.
01:27:52 SPEAKER_002: What Art said.
01:27:53 SPEAKER_016: I mean, just like we switched to wind turbines, we made the grid more complex and unstable.
01:27:59 SPEAKER_016: Same time, it goes back to not actually understanding what the problem is.
01:28:03 SPEAKER_016: I get flogged all the time.
01:28:05 SPEAKER_016: Everybody wants you want me to keep your lights on, but you don't like me burning coal.
01:28:09 SPEAKER_016: I don't hear any good solutions out there.
01:28:13 SPEAKER_016: All right, David, you had it for a while.
01:28:15 SPEAKER_016: I did.
01:28:16 SPEAKER_016: Thank you.
01:28:16 SPEAKER_016: Thank you, Andrew.
01:28:17 SPEAKER_013: I just want to give one data point, and to Art: in Ontario, we have watersheds.
01:28:26 SPEAKER_013: I think the largest one is the Grand River watershed.
01:28:28 SPEAKER_013: This is where I'm grabbing my data from.
01:28:30 SPEAKER_013: And when we build infrastructure, we build it to what they call the 100-year storm.
01:28:35 SPEAKER_013: So in our case, it's 1954 Hurricane Hazel.
01:28:39 SPEAKER_013: In the last 10 years, this is true.
01:28:42 SPEAKER_013: In the last 10 years, the Grand River watershed has been hit by the 100-year storm five times over the last 10 years.
01:28:48 SPEAKER_013: So whether we know the exact solution or how to fix what's coming, I don't know.
01:28:53 SPEAKER_013: But I think we got to learn to adapt, if nothing else.
01:28:57 SPEAKER_013: So just wanted to throw that data point out there.
01:29:02 SPEAKER_015: Parts of Houston have been hit by 500-year storms several times in the last 10 years.
01:29:08 SPEAKER_015: You guys ain't got nothing.
01:29:12 SPEAKER_011: Well, you know, I'm with David.
01:29:20 SPEAKER_011: We are an amazingly adaptive species.
01:29:23 SPEAKER_011: For anybody who's interested, I wrote seven essays on climate change, and I started looking at it.
01:29:31 SPEAKER_011: I wanted to.
01:29:33 SPEAKER_011: I'm a geologist, so I started five hundred million years ago.
01:29:36 SPEAKER_011: If you want to understand climate change, and how adaptable the Earth systems and its life systems are, take a look at some of those essays.
01:29:50 SPEAKER_011: They're free.
01:29:50 SPEAKER_011: There's no ads on my website.
01:29:53 SPEAKER_011: I don't claim them to be the truth, but they are the closest thing to an honest accounting as I can give.
01:30:00 SPEAKER_011: We this is an adaptive system.
01:30:03 SPEAKER_011: That doesn't mean that things are going to work out the way we like them.
01:30:08 SPEAKER_011: It just means you know the Earth will adapt, and I don't think humans will become extinct.
01:30:14 SPEAKER_011: We could.
01:30:15 SPEAKER_011: But the most likely case if we do is from nuclear weapons and not from climate change.
01:30:24 SPEAKER_011: But we won't like what climate change does to our lifestyles or our population.
01:30:30 SPEAKER_011: We won't like that a bit.
01:30:31 SPEAKER_011: But again, you know, it isn't.
01:30:34 SPEAKER_011: You know, we don't.
01:30:34 SPEAKER_011: It's not a popularity contest.
01:30:38 SPEAKER_011: A lot of what's going to happen is already pretty much set, and that doesn't mean we should give up, and you know, and woe is me.
01:30:49 SPEAKER_011: But it means we should be thinking more about how do we learn to live with it, as opposed to let's try to fix it.
01:31:01 SPEAKER_011: I got to run, guys.
01:31:02 SPEAKER_011: My car is calling me.
01:31:03 SPEAKER_011: They want my money.
01:31:05 SPEAKER_011: They want my natural resources.
01:31:07 SPEAKER_011: My claims on energy futures.
01:31:09 SPEAKER_011: Okay.
01:31:10 SPEAKER_011: Well, thank you so much, Art, for joining us.
01:31:13 SPEAKER_011: Thank you for putting up with me having to do this at the car dealership.
01:31:18 SPEAKER_011: But that's just what happened to me today.
01:31:19 SPEAKER_011: Yeah, I was actually at the mechanic today too.
01:31:24 SPEAKER_011: Thank you, Art.
01:31:25 SPEAKER_011: Okay.
01:31:26 SPEAKER_011: Yeah.
01:31:26 SPEAKER_011: All right.
01:31:26 SPEAKER_011: Take care, guys.
01:31:27 SPEAKER_011: Yeah.
01:31:30 SPEAKER_011: All right.
01:31:31 SPEAKER_011: All right.
01:31:32 SPEAKER_002: There's still a few more YouTube questions.
01:31:36 SPEAKER_002: I don't know if we wanted to try to get to them.
01:31:40 SPEAKER_002: Um.
01:31:43 SPEAKER_002: So about civilization collapses, long-term thinking.
01:31:49 SPEAKER_002: They were asking Art about the difference between reserves and inventory.
01:31:56 SPEAKER_002: I don't know.
01:31:57 SPEAKER_002: Did anyone have any quick comments on that?
01:32:00 SPEAKER_002: I guess before we close.
01:32:03 SPEAKER_016: Well, I'd like to add something, and as goes back to Roger Bentley and the paper that we had published.
01:32:11 SPEAKER_016: What the basic gist of that paper was was the governments are stating that we have something like six hundred billion barrels in reserves of crude oil, but if you go through the data from Exxon,
01:32:23 SPEAKER_016: Rystad, you know all the different oil companies, it's less than seven hundred billion, right?
01:32:29 SPEAKER_016: So that's less than half, and that goes back to Rystad and any oil guy that will tell you that look, there's a lot of oil that we haven't discovered yet,
01:32:38 SPEAKER_016: and the places where we haven't looked are going to be very expensive because you know they're 600 miles off the coast of Louisiana.
01:32:46 SPEAKER_016: And so if you want to know how this is going to play out in society, the prices are going to steadily go up.
01:32:51 SPEAKER_016: Now I wish Art was here, but I have crews over in Ohio drilling for shale gas, and even when we made that process more efficient, we actually put more steel in the ground, more fracks,
01:33:03 SPEAKER_016: and all those costs are going up.
Breakeven Prices and Production Peak Trends
The discussion examines how low WTI prices prevent drilling in regions like the United States and Venezuela due to high breakeven costs. One speaker clarifies that while official SEC reserves appear stable, actual conventional production peaked decades ago despite temporary increases from shale gas liquids. The conversation concludes by noting that most energy sources are past their production peaks, with only shale gas liquids projected to rise until the 2040s.
01:33:05 SPEAKER_016: And I know guys that drill oil here in the United States.
01:33:09 SPEAKER_016: If the WTI falls underneath seventy bucks, the wells don't get drilled.
01:33:15 SPEAKER_016: A good example of Venezuela: if WTI is under ninety, nobody does anything for Venezuela because the breakeven is ninety dollars.
01:33:24 SPEAKER_016: That's not profit; that's just breakeven.
01:33:26 SPEAKER_016: And those numbers are from Russia as far as what's going on down there.
01:33:30 SPEAKER_016: So what does that mean?
01:33:31 SPEAKER_016: That means the prices are steadily gonna go up, and it's gonna steadily create inflation.
01:33:34 SPEAKER_016: And it's going to steadily create inflation in our economy, which is what we're all seeing.
01:33:38 SPEAKER_016: So, and so it goes back to we're going to have to come to a decision.
01:33:42 SPEAKER_016: How are we going to adapt to this?
01:33:44 SPEAKER_016: You know, and that's that's what we're going to go through.
01:33:48 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, I'd like to add some clarity for some people in terms of because the reserves here, Art was using the official one P reserves, which are published by the SEC.
01:34:03 SPEAKER_002: And so their reserve numbers always go up, no matter what, because that's what's good for the stock investor, shareholder economy.
01:34:16 SPEAKER_002: But if we actually look at the numbers, the actual peak was in the nineteen eighties, and has been going down since.
01:34:25 SPEAKER_002: I don't have those charts on me right now, but this was the Jean LeHerrier one, and he had the conventional peak in 2005, and then here is the shale gas over here,
01:34:43 SPEAKER_002: which Dan was just talking about.
01:34:45 SPEAKER_002: You see, it's that blip, but this blip has offset this green part going down, and so that is why we had increased production.
01:34:56 SPEAKER_002: And then there's also the NGPL, and correct me if I'm wrong.
01:35:00 SPEAKER_002: Is that the shale liquids or, yeah, yeah, shale gas liquids, yeah, shale gas liquids.
01:35:06 SPEAKER_002: So shale gas liquids are still projected to continue to increase until the twenty forty s, but everything else will be going down at the same time.
01:35:17 SPEAKER_002: And as you can see, most of these other things are past peak in production, and these are based on fairly rigorous Hubbert linearization of different processes, so we can be fair.
High Prices as Proxy for Falling Energy Return
Speakers discuss how rising costs and tariffs increase production expenses without necessarily reflecting true supply availability. One participant argues that high prices serve as a proxy for declining energy return on investment, noting that extracting more oil yields less usable energy globally. The discussion concludes by suggesting that institutions will fail if the energy required to extract resources exceeds the energy gained from those resources.
01:35:32 SPEAKER_002: The thing about and understand that's supply.
01:35:34 SPEAKER_002: That doesn't include price.
01:35:35 SPEAKER_016: A lot of things can cause costs to go up.
01:35:38 SPEAKER_016: For example, President Trump when he put tariffs on steel drill steel pipe drill pipe, increased the cost of production.
01:35:48 SPEAKER_016: Or for example, what we're seeing right now in refineries, which high diesel prices, but maybe low oil prices.
01:35:54 SPEAKER_016: I mean, that's you know, that's one of the things that I talk about.
01:35:58 SPEAKER_016: People say, "Well, Daniel, production is going up."
01:36:00 SPEAKER_016: I said, "Yeah, but the prices would go to the point where you won't be able to afford the product, even though it's there, you just won't be able to afford it."
01:36:07 SPEAKER_015: And that's you know, it's not just priced in fiat dollars, though.
01:36:11 SPEAKER_015: It's also the energy return on getting some of these back.
01:36:15 SPEAKER_015: Yeah, you're right.
01:36:16 SPEAKER_015: The energy return is falling, Barbara.
01:36:18 SPEAKER_015: You're absolutely right.
01:36:18 SPEAKER_015: We're putting more stuff in the ground.
01:36:20 SPEAKER_015: The closer to zero it gets, it doesn't matter how many dollars I pour into it.
01:36:25 SPEAKER_015: If I end up putting a barrel in and getting a half barrel back, I am in deep trouble.
01:36:30 SPEAKER_015: I agree.
01:36:30 SPEAKER_016: If you put a barrel in, you don't only get a barrel out; it's not going to be worth drilling.
01:36:34 SPEAKER_016: Absolutely, absolutely true.
01:36:36 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, yeah, that's the energy return on investment that Charlie likes talking about, David.
01:36:44 SPEAKER_013: But for just throughout what I was going to say, going back to what Dan is saying, you talk about the high prices.
01:36:49 SPEAKER_013: High prices, as Barbara pointed out, I think high prices are just a proxy for a falling energy return on energy investment, and I know, yeah, we see overall growth in oil supply going up.
01:37:02 SPEAKER_013: But at the end of the day, if you put it in terms of energy, how much energy are we getting on that production?
01:37:10 SPEAKER_013: I think we're actually seeing falling energy, even though we're pulling more out of the ground worldwide.
01:37:15 SPEAKER_013: I think we're actually getting less energy out.
01:37:18 SPEAKER_013: And I'd love to see that kind of data.
01:37:20 SPEAKER_013: I know it's not easy to put together.
01:37:22 SPEAKER_013: And then as that falls, you'll see, you know, as they said before, institutions fail, right?
01:37:28 SPEAKER_013: You'll see the medical system falling, while it's failing now.
01:37:31 SPEAKER_013: You'll see higher education falling, things like that.
01:37:34 SPEAKER_013: So, yeah, getting back higher prices, I think again, are just a proxy for falling energy return on energy invested.
01:37:41 SPEAKER_013: That's how I see it.
01:37:42 SPEAKER_013: That's how.
01:37:42 SPEAKER_013: No, you're absolutely right, David.
01:37:43 SPEAKER_016: If it costs two hundred dollars a barrel to pull out of the ground, you can't afford to pay the two hundred dollars.
01:37:48 SPEAKER_016: Therefore, we're not going to do it.
01:37:51 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, the price is the proxy for this issue.
Food Prices, Ethanol Efficiency, and Syngas Technology
Speakers discuss the correlation between rising global food prices since 2014 and declining agricultural inventories. The conversation highlights the inefficiency of corn ethanol, noting that its energy output is nearly one-to-one with input costs due to high fertilizer requirements. Participants also examine syngas technology derived from natural gas for producing synthetic fuels and electricity.
01:37:55 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, and there was actually a good part of the inventory is going down, and see it was in 2014, and so this is actually a very good correspondence to food prices.
01:38:09 SPEAKER_002: Global food prices have been steadily rising since 2014, 2015, and so that's a direct correlation because if 2014 prices is when it started to go up.
01:38:22 SPEAKER_002: You know, the food prices usually lag by a few months to a year, and so 2015.
01:38:28 SPEAKER_002: And world hunger has been increasing, and all of that.
01:38:30 SPEAKER_002: So that was basically a tipping point.
01:38:33 SPEAKER_002: And so here it's shown by the inventories, even though you know the reserves may be skewed in this graph.
01:38:46 SPEAKER_015: But a lot of that is localization and a complex globalization and the complexity issue on food prices.
01:38:52 SPEAKER_015: For example, Iowans get only ten percent of their food grown in the state, which is appalling.
01:39:00 SPEAKER_015: Because some of it actually goes to Asia for processing and comes back.
01:39:07 SPEAKER_015: So it has all of the transportation costs in it.
01:39:10 SPEAKER_015: And I think your point earlier on, great, you know, we could go back to the land in a bigger way, and localize agriculture,
01:39:22 SPEAKER_015: and find that food prices didn't need to be nearly so expensive as they are right now.
01:39:30 SPEAKER_002: Well, yeah, that has to do with the distribution, right?
01:39:33 SPEAKER_015: And yeah, the global distribution and no access to local foods.
01:39:39 SPEAKER_015: Right.
01:39:40 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, and the land distribution is what I meant, and there's a large, hard-to-understand political headwind against letting people have land.
01:39:50 SPEAKER_002: So, yeah, yes, globally, right?
01:39:54 SPEAKER_002: But now, wait a minute, Andre.
01:39:56 SPEAKER_002: Let's be fair.
01:39:57 SPEAKER_015: If we all wanted to be surfers and go work on Bill Gates' land as surfers, I'm sure he would be happy to let us have access to the land.
01:40:06 SPEAKER_002: Well, yeah, I meant land ownership, of course.
01:40:11 SPEAKER_002: Um, but yeah, so I did find one of John Peach's earlier slides, and it has that little bit about the discoveries that we had mentioned.
01:40:22 SPEAKER_002: And so you could see that the discoveries have been declining, and so our total fracking and conventional era.
01:40:33 SPEAKER_002: Anyhow, okay.
01:40:34 SPEAKER_002: So I'll double check the YouTube, and if otherwise, if no one else has anything, we can close up here.
01:40:45 SPEAKER_002: Here's a question: How much high-quality diesel and other petroleum fuels and natural gas fertilizer per unit of corn ethanol energy?
01:40:54 SPEAKER_002: If anyone knows that off the top of their head, it's less than nothing.
01:40:58 SPEAKER_002: It's less than nothing because you have there been some great studies.
01:41:02 SPEAKER_004: You have spent so much to make the fuel that it's like you know.
01:41:08 SPEAKER_004: Okay, you could take your corn and turn it into fuel, but it's really like it's like a one-to-one.
01:41:16 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, one-to-one.
01:41:16 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, they claim it two-to-one.
01:41:22 SPEAKER_015: But the BTUs in the ethanol are approximately half, so it's darn close to one-to-one.
01:41:28 SPEAKER_015: Yeah.
01:41:30 SPEAKER_004: As a friend of mine said, you can drink or you can drive.
01:41:35 SPEAKER_004: You know, because you can turn corn into whiskey, or you can drive around.
01:41:39 SPEAKER_004: Or you could drive around on it, right?
01:41:41 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, it all goes back to phosphate and ammonium nitrate, and those crops require a lot of it.
01:41:47 SPEAKER_016: And if fertilizer prices are high, it's not economical.
01:41:50 SPEAKER_016: I mean, in best of times, it's one point one, and if you think about it, one point one, you turn sunlight into fuel, but it's not a great positive.
01:42:01 SPEAKER_016: It helps us; we get cleaner, but we're burning fuel.
01:42:04 SPEAKER_016: I guess I'd give it that way.
01:42:07 SPEAKER_004: I've heard it was because they wanted to jack up the octane in fuels.
01:42:11 SPEAKER_004: Yes, yeah, it helps.
01:42:13 SPEAKER_016: Higher temperatures, you burn the fuel more efficiently in your car.
01:42:19 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
01:42:20 SPEAKER_015: And Exxon is also producing some of it as well, so that they're working on both ends.
01:42:27 SPEAKER_015: Right.
01:42:28 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, their process; they're turning natural gas into methanol and ethanol.
01:42:32 SPEAKER_016: So that's just all that syngas technology.
01:42:35 SPEAKER_016: We turn it into synthetic stuff.
01:42:40 SPEAKER_016: That's got to be a lot higher EROEI.
01:42:42 SPEAKER_016: Also, the syngas.
01:42:44 SPEAKER_016: It all goes back to the natural gas.
01:42:46 SPEAKER_016: I mean, right now we've got numbers that say, like I said, that summer 2028, we're still going to have you know an energy crisis here in the states due to natural gas,
01:42:56 SPEAKER_016: and it's not an infinite resource.
01:42:58 SPEAKER_016: It has limits to it.
01:42:59 SPEAKER_016: I mean, Europe's going through the energy crisis right now.
01:43:02 SPEAKER_016: So if you produce this.
01:43:04 SPEAKER_015: So if you produce syngas from biofuels rather than from any kind of fossil fuels, have you?
01:43:13 SPEAKER_015: I've not seen anybody even trying it because of course fossil fuels.
01:43:17 SPEAKER_015: Yeah, they do.
01:43:18 SPEAKER_015: They do that over Wabash Valley, Wabash, Indiana.
01:43:21 SPEAKER_015: There's a power plant over there.
01:43:23 SPEAKER_016: We pretty much turn anything with carbon can be gasified, and most of the time they burn the syngas into about four GEHA seven HA gas turbines for making electricity.
01:43:34 SPEAKER_016: They call it clean coal technology.
01:43:36 SPEAKER_016: The truth is, it's about four centuries old.
01:43:38 SPEAKER_016: But they also use it to do other things.
01:43:41 SPEAKER_016: For example, Lilly turns syngas into drugs.
01:43:45 SPEAKER_016: So right now, they're talking about Wabash Valley.
Economic Limits of Extracting Ground Oil
Speakers discuss how two-thirds of subsurface oil remains economically unviable to extract due to high costs and energy requirements. One participant cites a failed Halliburton project in Wyoming where carbon dioxide injection improved production by only four percent before leaking into a school caused shutdowns. Another speaker argues that deep asphalt deposits are likely stuck in the ground rather than being recoverable resources, noting that ammonia production from farm waste is also a practical alternative.
01:43:47 SPEAKER_016: Actually, they're going to start producing ammonia with that process because that's a way of making anhydrous ammonia without using natural gas.
01:43:56 SPEAKER_016: Because those processes built on syngas.
01:43:58 SPEAKER_015: So, so those seem to be a lot more practical than driving your diesel through the cornfield, right?
01:44:06 SPEAKER_015: Yeah, Wabash Valley is rather interesting place.
01:44:08 SPEAKER_016: Half of it's owned by Duke, and the other half is owned by coops.
01:44:11 SPEAKER_016: And so, yeah, they pump a lot of farm waste through this syn gas plant to produce electricity.
01:44:17 SPEAKER_016: A lot of people are rather surprised by this.
01:44:19 SPEAKER_016: Like you guys aren't using coal, Mike.
01:44:21 SPEAKER_016: We haven't used coal for 25 years.
01:44:22 SPEAKER_016: I use basically farm waste.
01:44:24 SPEAKER_016: Basically, all the corn stalks is get what's get fed into the plant.
01:44:26 SPEAKER_015: So that that is a big deal now that the corn stocks can no longer be plowed back into the field the way they were 40 years ago, right?
01:44:36 SPEAKER_015: Right.
01:44:37 SPEAKER_015: And they have to be removed, right?
01:44:39 SPEAKER_015: So using them is a good idea.
01:44:42 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, they're using all kinds of farm waste in that plant, so that's all good stuff.
01:44:46 SPEAKER_016: I know in Europe they actually turn trash into syn gas, and they use it for making all kinds of synthetics.
01:44:53 SPEAKER_016: So that's a good option.
01:44:57 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, and just to Dan's point about the natural gas, I had from Jean Leherre.
01:45:06 SPEAKER_002: This is the Huber linearization, and so while he says that we're basically at the peak and slightly past the peak of natural gas globally.
01:45:19 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, that's conventional natural gas.
01:45:21 SPEAKER_002: Conventional, yeah, yeah, conventional.
01:45:22 SPEAKER_002: And then the NGPL, we're still on the ascent.
01:45:27 SPEAKER_002: So, so that would be... the, or is that?
01:45:29 SPEAKER_002: Oh, this is the shale gas here.
01:45:31 SPEAKER_002: Shale gas, we're approaching the peak.
01:45:34 SPEAKER_002: But the NGPL, we still got some headroom.
01:45:39 SPEAKER_002: Petroleum liquids, natural gas, petroleum liquids.
01:45:43 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
01:45:45 SPEAKER_002: All right.
01:45:47 SPEAKER_002: Okay, so in terms of next time, I think that we will probably do it in January because December is pretty busy.
01:45:55 SPEAKER_002: Because December's pretty busy and there haven't been a lot of requests, so if anyone has any ideas over the next month or two, that'd be great.
01:46:05 SPEAKER_002: I'm going to try and Andre.
01:46:09 SPEAKER_002: I was going to try and have my presentation done.
01:46:11 SPEAKER_002: Okay, just so you know.
01:46:12 SPEAKER_002: Oh, okay.
01:46:13 SPEAKER_002: For you're going to try to have it done for December.
01:46:17 SPEAKER_002: I'll do it as soon as I can.
01:46:19 SPEAKER_002: Let's put that.
01:46:20 SPEAKER_002: Okay, sure.
01:46:20 SPEAKER_013: I was hoping to have it ready, you know, before this cold weather starts setting in our part of the world.
01:46:26 SPEAKER_013: So, but it's...
01:46:28 SPEAKER_013: I put numbers to everything, and it's just off-the-shelf items.
01:46:30 SPEAKER_013: But it's, it's, it's...
01:46:32 SPEAKER_013: I think it's very practical and good to know.
01:46:35 SPEAKER_002: So it was about energy efficiency.
01:46:38 SPEAKER_002: Um, just trying to get your house to net zero.
01:46:41 SPEAKER_002: Anybody could do it, right?
01:46:43 SPEAKER_002: It's just a matter of...
01:46:44 SPEAKER_002: I know I've in an economical fashion.
01:46:47 SPEAKER_002: You know, I've ever had a very similar idea.
01:46:50 SPEAKER_002: So I don't know if the two of you wanted to.
01:46:53 SPEAKER_002: Sure, both presents or something.
01:46:55 SPEAKER_004: Sure, I'm doing a couple of videos with a friend.
01:46:58 SPEAKER_004: I do these kind of fun videos about ways to sort of save energy and save money, and so I got ideas already.
01:47:09 SPEAKER_013: I use building science, right, and hands-on and stuff I've learned over the years.
01:47:17 SPEAKER_013: That's great.
01:47:18 SPEAKER_013: That's great.
01:47:19 SPEAKER_013: Nice.
01:47:19 SPEAKER_002: Okay, so maybe maybe in December then.
01:47:22 SPEAKER_002: I guess you guys will keep me updated for when you're ready, and then so possibly we'll do it in December.
01:47:30 SPEAKER_004: Otherwise, can you put your number on in the chat, David?
01:47:36 SPEAKER_004: Yes, I will do that.
01:47:37 SPEAKER_004: That way we can communicate.
01:47:41 SPEAKER_002: And so let me just see what else.
01:47:48 SPEAKER_002: How much high-quality diesel and other petroleum fuels and natural gas fertilizer.
01:47:53 SPEAKER_002: Oh, okay, we already did that one.
01:47:55 SPEAKER_002: Okay, Art's always saying there's plenty of supply.
01:48:02 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, we don't quite know why he does that.
01:48:06 SPEAKER_016: Well, Art says there's plenty of supply, and what that is is two-thirds of the stuff that's in the ground isn't going to come out.
01:48:15 SPEAKER_016: You know, and I think Rogers talked about it too.
01:48:17 SPEAKER_016: You know, and Roger talked about...
01:48:19 SPEAKER_016: I guess, as an example, he talked about the North Sea.
01:48:21 SPEAKER_016: He said, "Yeah, if we... you know, an oil deposit, basically, it's a... you've got oil and you got natural gas, which usually mixed in with it, and on top,
01:48:29 SPEAKER_016: once that liquid stuff and the gases come out, what's left in there is a thick, basically asphalt that's still in the ground.
01:48:35 SPEAKER_016: Now, if you basically put a mining shaft down into it and actually physically mined it, you know, maybe you can get it out, but what are the costs going to be?
01:48:43 SPEAKER_016: Two hundred dollars a barrel, three hundred, five hundred dollars a barrel, ten thousand dollars a barrel?"
01:48:47 SPEAKER_016: That's what we're getting at.
01:48:49 SPEAKER_016: I mean, what's still in the ground is asphalt.
01:48:51 SPEAKER_016: And I got a little bit of experience with some of this up at a place called Salt Creek, which is north of Casper, Wyoming.
01:48:59 SPEAKER_016: The early part of about two thousand three, two thousand four, Halliburton was up there injecting carbon dioxide into that field.
01:49:07 SPEAKER_016: They used supercritical CO2 as a solvent to try to leach more of that asphalt out of the ground.
01:49:12 SPEAKER_016: By twenty fifteen, they ended up shutting it down because CO2 is leaking into a school.
01:49:18 SPEAKER_016: Oh my gosh!
01:49:19 SPEAKER_016: And they only... and they only improved the production by like an extra three or four percent.
01:49:24 SPEAKER_016: So the point is, is two-thirds of that stuff is going to be stuck in the ground, and I know it's just going to drive Art crazy.
01:49:30 SPEAKER_016: But it's just not economical to get out.
01:49:33 SPEAKER_015: I mean, think about if it were economical, it might take more energy.
01:49:38 SPEAKER_015: Think about it, Barbara.
01:49:39 SPEAKER_015: You're digging down six thousand feet.
Local Adaptation Strategies for Resource Decline
Speakers discuss how deep mines and geothermal energy represent alternative energy sources as hydrocarbon reserves become inaccessible. They note that abandoned assets like the Salt Creek site remain unused because supercritical CO2 extraction is not economically viable at current gas prices. The conversation highlights that high interest rates reduce monetary liquidity, which creates downward pressure on oil prices while simultaneously harming household affordability. Ultimately, participants argue that meaningful change requires local communities to adapt by utilising existing resources rather than relying on government solutions.
01:49:41 SPEAKER_016: I mean, think about some of the deepest mines we have now that like... in Africa, for like gold or something, they're they're like two miles deep or something like that.
01:49:49 SPEAKER_016: You're talking about six thousand, seven thousand feet, and then think about the temperatures.
01:49:54 SPEAKER_016: I know, for example, down in Evansville, the water comes out of the ground hot, guys.
01:49:59 SPEAKER_016: I mean, it's you know, it's eighty, ninety degrees Celsius coming out of the ground.
01:50:04 SPEAKER_016: So you can... an energy source, guys, an energy source.
01:50:07 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, well, and that's what we do.
01:50:09 SPEAKER_016: For example, up in Buffalo, New York, rather than plugging the natural gas wells up there, they start pumping the hot water coming out of the wells through the houses, so it is an energy source.
01:50:19 SPEAKER_016: But that goes back to geothermal thing I'm talking about, Barbara.
01:50:22 SPEAKER_016: But but the practical aspects: two-thirds those hydrocarbons are going to stay in the ground because, like I said, it's... it's... it's not liquid oil, guys.
01:50:29 SPEAKER_016: It's asphalt, the stuff out in front of your street.
01:50:35 SPEAKER_015: I mean, and meanwhile we have no asphalt to pave our streets.
01:50:40 SPEAKER_015: Well, that's a byproduct of a refinery, but but you understand what I'm getting at.
01:50:43 SPEAKER_016: I mean, Halliburton they abandoned Salt Creek in 2015 and turned it over to the Department of Energy, and the Department of Energy hasn't done anything with it.
01:50:52 SPEAKER_016: It's just an asset on their book.
01:50:54 SPEAKER_016: But yeah, but yeah, I mean, that was using supercritical CO2, which is a solvent, you know, to try to... and and they... you know they kind of gave up,
01:51:03 SPEAKER_016: and they don't generally talk about their failures, but that's the thing.
01:51:08 SPEAKER_016: It's just like they talk about you can do more drilling over the North Sea in England.
01:51:12 SPEAKER_016: The truth is, I've seen the church.
01:51:13 SPEAKER_016: It's just gas.
01:51:14 SPEAKER_016: The only thing you're going to get out of is gas.
01:51:17 SPEAKER_016: So until the prices of gas go up high enough, it's just not economical to produce.
01:51:21 SPEAKER_016: Even though, so they say, oh, we just haven't drilled enough.
01:51:24 SPEAKER_016: Like, no, it's not economical to produce.
01:51:27 SPEAKER_016: It's not oil.
01:51:28 SPEAKER_016: It's gas.
01:51:30 SPEAKER_015: And then on the demand side, there's the affordability issue, right?
01:51:35 SPEAKER_015: Yeah.
01:51:35 SPEAKER_015: So okay, so I'm going to get charged... you know, a hundred dollars for the natural gas versus what?
01:51:44 SPEAKER_015: Three is it now?
01:51:45 SPEAKER_015: I forget what I didn't look recently.
01:51:47 SPEAKER_015: Uh, but who's going to be able to afford that?
01:51:51 SPEAKER_015: Yeah, I mean, afford it for what?
01:51:52 SPEAKER_015: Right?
01:51:52 SPEAKER_015: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:51:53 SPEAKER_016: I mean, we pay you know three dollars, four dollars for per million BTUs.
01:51:58 SPEAKER_016: Over there, you're talking twenty-five, thirty dollars per million BTUs.
01:52:02 SPEAKER_016: I mean, yeah.
01:52:02 SPEAKER_016: I mean, at which point does the customer say, "I can't do this"?
01:52:06 SPEAKER_016: Do I just... you know wrap up in blankets and shiver in my house?
01:52:09 SPEAKER_016: I mean, that's I'm being practical about what's going to happen.
01:52:13 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
01:52:16 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
01:52:16 SPEAKER_002: So I just wanted to just quickly share this chart here about the liquidity relationship.
01:52:25 SPEAKER_002: So basically, this is monetary liquidity, and it has much higher relationship to the price of oil than almost anything else, and it has a five, four to five months lead time.
01:52:40 SPEAKER_002: So you see, like this is... if it was at zero months, and but in order to get it to align, it's like a five, five months,
01:52:49 SPEAKER_002: and that means based on the monetary policy that governments are like making money more easily accessible than people naturally use that money in order to buy oil,
01:53:03 SPEAKER_002: and then the price of oil goes up within the next several months because of how long it takes to get through the system.
01:53:12 SPEAKER_002: And so we can actually see, and as right now we're seeing the monetary supply going down, and that's because of high interest rates.
01:53:26 SPEAKER_002: And so that puts a downward pressure on the monetary supply,
01:53:30 SPEAKER_002: and so the price of oil can actually go down simply because there's less people with money that they can use in order to buy stuff.
01:53:40 SPEAKER_002: But the average man on the street isn't going to be having a job, and they're going to have trouble buying food or getting housing and things like that.
01:53:50 SPEAKER_002: So it's kind of like the price can be very deceptive.
01:53:53 SPEAKER_002: It's really has you know it's more about what's the quality of life on the street.
01:53:58 SPEAKER_002: Demand destruction exactly.
01:54:00 SPEAKER_002: Demand destruction, and it's been going down since about 2014, and that was quite in line with the inventories going down.
01:54:08 SPEAKER_002: So, and we saw that from Art's chart as well.
01:54:12 SPEAKER_016: And that's kind of one of the unfortunate things about this.
01:54:15 SPEAKER_016: You know, just my experience over the last you know 30 some odd years doing this, the governments will keep try to keep the existing system going on,
01:54:24 SPEAKER_016: and that includes trying to juice with easy money.
01:54:27 SPEAKER_016: The only people that I can see that have...
01:54:28 SPEAKER_016: That I can see that are actually making changes are at the local level, right?
01:54:33 SPEAKER_016: It's actually at the town level.
01:54:34 SPEAKER_016: That's where changes are being made.
01:54:36 SPEAKER_016: People are deciding, figuring out that they're not going to help me.
01:54:39 SPEAKER_016: I've got to make this.
01:54:40 SPEAKER_016: I got to fix it myself.
01:54:41 SPEAKER_016: Like the town up in Buffalo, New York, that basically decided rather than spending six million dollars plugging those natural gas wells, we're going to take that hot water and use it to heat homes.
01:54:51 SPEAKER_016: You know, that's where that's what's going to have to happen.
01:54:54 SPEAKER_016: People are going to have to come to that realization.
01:54:56 SPEAKER_016: We can't keep doing this.
01:54:58 SPEAKER_016: We have to adapt in a different way.
01:55:01 SPEAKER_002: And well, that kind of public willingness also takes time, you know, because people have to get informed about it.
01:55:10 SPEAKER_002: They need to get the seed of the idea, and then it needs to grow in them until you know they are like, "You know what?
01:55:16 SPEAKER_002: I will vote for this new thing," because when they hear about it the first time, they're like, "What is this?
01:55:24 SPEAKER_002: Who came up with this idea?"
01:55:25 SPEAKER_002: That oil isn't...
01:55:26 SPEAKER_002: This idea that oil is not infinite, you know, because nobody taught them, and they think growth is forever.
01:55:31 SPEAKER_002: There's a lot of kind of inertia because a lot of people haven't recalibrated to the fact that we are in a resource decline scenario.
Climate Change Impacts on Agriculture and Wildlife
Speakers discuss how changing weather patterns disrupt local ecosystems, causing fruit trees to fail and snowmobile trails to disappear due to insufficient snow. They note that some industry participants are adapting their businesses to these new realities while others struggle to accept the shift away from resource growth scenarios.
01:55:40 SPEAKER_002: We're no longer in a resource growth scenario.
01:55:44 SPEAKER_016: I do have an update to my geothermal presentation, but my biggest impediment is basically the times when you do these.
01:55:52 SPEAKER_016: Usually, the second and third week of the month are really hard for me to do presentations.
01:55:57 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, because that's the time of the month where I'm usually loaded.
01:56:00 SPEAKER_016: Usually, people don't let me touch stuff at the end of the month and first part of the month.
01:56:04 SPEAKER_016: So usually, the middle of the month is when we're really, really busy.
01:56:09 SPEAKER_002: So if I do it within the first two weeks, it would be okay.
01:56:13 SPEAKER_016: If you do it within, say, the first week in December, that would help out.
01:56:16 SPEAKER_016: First week of December.
01:56:17 SPEAKER_016: Okay.
01:56:17 SPEAKER_016: Well, we'll see.
01:56:19 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, we might be able to do that if David and Ivor have their stuff ready.
01:56:23 SPEAKER_002: We could do first week of December.
01:56:26 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, yeah.
01:56:28 SPEAKER_016: I've got a lot of good stuff from the drillers, and I have to remind everybody.
01:56:31 SPEAKER_016: Everybody's always surprised of like, "Why would the neighbours get involved?"
01:56:35 SPEAKER_016: I said, well, because they're the ones wildcating.
01:56:38 SPEAKER_016: They're the ones discovering the new oil fields.
01:56:40 SPEAKER_016: They're seeing less and less business.
01:56:42 SPEAKER_016: They're adapting their business to the reality.
01:56:44 SPEAKER_016: I mean, that's what's going on.
01:56:48 SPEAKER_016: Not necessarily everybody in the industry is adapting, but those that are, they're looking ahead, and they got another forty or fifty or sixty years in their career.
01:56:57 SPEAKER_016: That's what they're looking at.
01:56:58 SPEAKER_016: So I don't know how else to describe it.
01:57:01 SPEAKER_016: Some people willing to adapt, and others just aren't.
01:57:04 SPEAKER_016: They just aren't willing to accept it.
01:57:07 SPEAKER_016: I guess.
01:57:09 SPEAKER_002: David, did you have any comments on the political aspect?
01:57:15 SPEAKER_013: No, well, no. I think what you said was perfect.
01:57:18 SPEAKER_013: I mean, those ideas, you got to get them out.
01:57:19 SPEAKER_013: That you got to get them out there, and it does take people a little while to change to accept them.
01:57:25 SPEAKER_013: So, speaking of change, I don't know how long you've been following Art Berman, but I've probably been following for twenty years, and he has changed.
01:57:32 SPEAKER_013: A lot of people notice that.
01:57:33 SPEAKER_013: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:57:35 SPEAKER_013: And I have my suspicions about why.
01:57:39 SPEAKER_013: I know he's put up with some abuse, you know, over the years, but he's definitely changed.
01:57:44 SPEAKER_013: So, yeah, interesting.
01:57:46 SPEAKER_013: Just interesting to hear him today.
01:57:49 SPEAKER_013: Yeah, yeah.
01:57:50 SPEAKER_013: I mean, he's thinking.
01:57:53 SPEAKER_004: He's been talking about a lot of stuff, and you know, it is hard to... you know, you can't do the blame game on things.
01:58:01 SPEAKER_004: But one thing I've heard is, you know, when you're in a hole, first thing to do is stop digging.
01:58:07 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, yeah.
01:58:08 SPEAKER_004: So I think we're at that point where we're beginning to realize, okay, we're way down in this hole.
01:58:15 SPEAKER_004: I think we've come a long way, you know.
01:58:17 SPEAKER_016: Just we can have this conversation because I can tell you, before I started doing these forums, I was flawed for years.
01:58:24 SPEAKER_016: You know, I have people.
01:58:25 SPEAKER_016: Dan, you're burning coal.
01:58:26 SPEAKER_016: You're evil.
01:58:27 SPEAKER_016: You're destroying the planet.
01:58:28 SPEAKER_016: I'm like, "Yeah, but by law, I have to keep your lights on."
01:58:31 SPEAKER_016: You know, I'm between a rock and a hard place.
01:58:33 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, yeah.
01:58:34 SPEAKER_016: But solutions... you know, guys don't like the answers.
01:58:36 SPEAKER_016: So what am I supposed to do?
01:58:38 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, it's great.
01:58:38 SPEAKER_016: I can sit there and talk to Ivor, and he says, "Dan, well, these are the issues and things I'm saying."
01:58:44 SPEAKER_016: That's those are things I need.
01:58:46 SPEAKER_016: But at the same time, I can say, "Either I'm between a rock and a hard place, brother.
01:58:50 SPEAKER_016: I need help, you know."
01:58:52 SPEAKER_016: And that's what's great about this.
01:58:54 SPEAKER_004: Well, I was just saying before, I hope we hold up this present situation for a while, and that we're all able to make it through the winter and things, you know,
01:59:05 SPEAKER_004: without it all going too crazy, you know.
01:59:08 SPEAKER_004: And I have to admit, selfishly, you know, I bought three hundred gallons of oil, and at four fifty, I felt like that was pretty good.
01:59:17 SPEAKER_004: Now this year, you know, and I'd like to make it through this winter.
01:59:21 SPEAKER_004: But you know, I'm not going...
01:59:22 SPEAKER_004: Should be a warm winter.
01:59:24 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, it should be good.
01:59:25 SPEAKER_004: I'm not going on any...
01:59:26 SPEAKER_002: Three and a half degrees above normal.
01:59:29 SPEAKER_002: Really?
01:59:30 SPEAKER_002: Well, at least in Canada, Canada is projected to be three and a half degrees above normal this winter.
01:59:35 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
01:59:36 SPEAKER_002: Oh, that is warm.
01:59:36 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
01:59:37 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
01:59:38 SPEAKER_002: You're talking Celsius too.
01:59:40 SPEAKER_002: Celsius.
01:59:40 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, I'm talking in Celsius.
01:59:41 SPEAKER_002: So that's seven degrees Fahrenheit.
01:59:42 SPEAKER_002: No, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:59:46 SPEAKER_016: Well, I wonder why Art basically adapted is because of things like that.
01:59:50 SPEAKER_016: If you go up in places in Canada, I know places up in northern Michigan that in the winter time they had like snowmobiling and stuff like that.
01:59:58 SPEAKER_016: Now they can't do it because they don't...
02:00:00 SPEAKER_016: Oh no, they have winters that don't have snow.
02:00:03 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, I've been watching the last bunch of winters, and a lot of people just took their snowmobiles out for like two weeks last year.
02:00:14 SPEAKER_004: I watch because I go cross-country skiing on a golf course.
02:00:16 SPEAKER_004: I only need this much snow, and these guys never got enough snow.
02:00:21 SPEAKER_004: Most of the time, I own quite a bit of land.
02:00:24 SPEAKER_016: I'm not a farmer or anything, but I have pear trees on my property, and I'm having problems with my pear trees and their cycle when they flower,
02:00:34 SPEAKER_016: because I've had a couple of them... we had a really, really weird spring.
02:00:38 SPEAKER_016: We got a freeze that killed the flowers, and then other times, usually they like to ripen right around August 15th.
02:00:45 SPEAKER_016: And now all that's messed up.
02:00:46 SPEAKER_016: I had pears rot right off the tree.
02:00:49 SPEAKER_016: It's because the cycle is screwed up, and the trees aren't adapting to the weather.
02:00:55 SPEAKER_016: So we're watching it in real time.
02:00:57 SPEAKER_016: And Dan, I'll just share our story too.
02:00:58 SPEAKER_016: I mean, we have this local snowmobile club, and God love them.
02:01:02 SPEAKER_016: Those guys were the most optimistic group I've ever met.
02:01:04 SPEAKER_013: Because year after year, they would put out all the signage.
02:01:07 SPEAKER_013: You know, "This is where you stop," and all this stuff, and there'd be not enough snow, right?
02:01:12 SPEAKER_013: So there'd be like... they might use it for one day, but they'd do it year after year.
02:01:15 SPEAKER_013: Finally, I think about four years ago they stopped doing it.
02:01:17 SPEAKER_013: But yeah, anybody that is a snowmobiler has to go further and further north.
02:01:22 SPEAKER_013: And I'm the same way.
02:01:23 SPEAKER_013: I got trees... fruit trees that they don't quite seem to know what to do.
02:01:28 SPEAKER_013: And yeah, you know, you're exactly what I'm talking about, David.
Shift from trucking to rail and barge transport
Speakers discuss how high inflation and fuel costs are driving a shift away from trucking toward more efficient rail and barge transport. They note that eighty percent of U.S. goods currently ship by truck, whereas Japan relies heavily on inexpensive domestic rail networks. The conversation highlights rising VLCC shipping costs and predicts that economic pressures may force a return to local supply chains in the mid-2030s.
02:01:30 SPEAKER_013: It is like the cycles messed up, and we lost ninety-five percent of our sweet and sour cherries this year, like across southern Ontario.
02:01:40 SPEAKER_016: So, my peach trees haven't yielded peaches for the last three years.
02:01:46 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, I'm kind of concerned about it.
02:01:48 SPEAKER_016: I think we're seeing the same thing here.
02:01:50 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, unfortunately.
02:01:52 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
02:01:53 SPEAKER_002: So, someone in the chat just said, "There's still snow-free in Alaska."
02:01:58 SPEAKER_002: Wow.
02:01:59 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
02:02:00 SPEAKER_002: Too many mosquitoes for me, and that's okay.
02:02:04 SPEAKER_002: I don't think the mosquitoes are... they almost carried away.
02:02:08 SPEAKER_002: They almost drugged me away.
02:02:11 SPEAKER_002: That's okay.
02:02:12 SPEAKER_002: So, in the chat, people are like... a lot of people are wondering about if there's going to be a collapse, but they're saying that probably it'll just be a managed decline.
02:02:22 SPEAKER_016: No, it'll be a slow inflationary drag is what'll happen.
02:02:27 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, yeah, and yeah, that seems to be consistent with a lot of models, though.
02:02:32 SPEAKER_002: Um, if...
02:02:33 SPEAKER_002: So, if we get interesting times, the projections I've seen it will be in the 2030s.
02:02:40 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, you know.
02:02:41 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, if you want to know why the bankers, why we're not seeing enough like refineries and drilling capacity and stuff like that, it goes back to the bankers, and the bankers are seeing the inflation,
02:02:49 SPEAKER_016: and that's why you're not seeing investing.
02:02:51 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, I know people say, "Oh, they haven't invested four trillion dollars."
02:02:54 SPEAKER_016: I'm like, "Yeah, because the bankers are not investing in it because of the inflation issues, and it's feeding back, and that's why they're not investing."
02:03:02 SPEAKER_016: It, so it's just the way it is.
02:03:07 SPEAKER_016: And yeah,
02:03:08 SPEAKER_002: I think to the point like Art was saying how you know... it's not about blaming people and it has more to do with that maximum power principle that Charlie and Charlie's student are we talking
02:03:24 SPEAKER_002: about... that it's the system working together and the system is maximizing the resources and it doesn't work the way that we think it does.
02:03:32 SPEAKER_002: I'll give some recommendations.
02:03:34 SPEAKER_016: I know I make a lot of people mad, but this has to do with having lived in other countries.
02:03:38 SPEAKER_016: A Navy brat, so I kind of grew up in Japan, right?
02:03:41 SPEAKER_016: Japan has a lot more rail and shipping, right?
02:03:44 SPEAKER_016: And because there are much more efficient ways of shipping things around versus the United States, eighty percent of our goods are shipped by truck, right?
02:03:53 SPEAKER_016: One of the things that'll probably play out with all this is we'll be forced into this much more efficient means of shipping things around, like barges up and down the Ohio-Mississippi River, rail,
02:04:04 SPEAKER_016: which is very, very efficient, right?
02:04:07 SPEAKER_016: And I know my wife; you know, because we like to go back to Japan and see family and stuff like that.
02:04:13 SPEAKER_016: Drive crazy, but we have to.
02:04:15 SPEAKER_016: She may have to take two or three months off to take a ship back-to-back to Asia, and that's because I mean you can see right now we've had some airlines go out of business.
02:04:25 SPEAKER_016: The price of jet fuel is going up, and eventually get to the point where the customers aren't going to fly and you'll lose airlines, and that's how this will play out.
02:04:34 SPEAKER_016: We're already seeing it in the shipping of oil.
02:04:36 SPEAKER_016: I mean, I watched before the Persian Gulf War; oil went.
02:04:40 SPEAKER_016: You know, shipping was like fifty thousand dollars a day for a ship.
02:04:43 SPEAKER_016: Now it's over a million dollars a day to get a VLCC.
02:04:47 SPEAKER_016: You know, to go from the Gulf of Oman to you know the ports there in Asia.
02:04:51 SPEAKER_016: You know, shipping's becoming a lot more expensive, and it's affecting a lot of things.
02:04:57 SPEAKER_016: Products coming out of Japan are becoming more expensive, therefore they're not being shipped to America.
02:05:02 SPEAKER_016: Americans aren't buying the stuff because of the prices, and it's all feeding on each other.
02:05:06 SPEAKER_016: So everything's going to become more and more local.
02:05:10 SPEAKER_016: That's how it is.
02:05:10 SPEAKER_002: And I did run the numbers on that, and so it would be, you know, relative to people's incomes, it would have to be five dollars a liter.
02:05:20 SPEAKER_002: So that would be what twenty dollars a gallon or something.
02:05:26 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
02:05:26 SPEAKER_002: In order to make it make sense to go back to rail, and so we may reach that sometime in the mid-20s.
02:05:37 SPEAKER_002: Well, I understand everybody's got independence.
02:05:39 SPEAKER_002: That's why we went and bought our automobiles.
02:05:41 SPEAKER_002: We had this independence, right?
02:05:43 SPEAKER_016: But if you're being driven back to rail, I mean, I understand.
02:05:46 SPEAKER_016: When I grew up in Japan, they don't drive.
02:05:48 SPEAKER_016: You know, back then we ride rail all over the place.
02:05:51 SPEAKER_016: You ride the trains.
02:05:52 SPEAKER_016: You know, it's more convenient to ride trains in Japan and Korea than it is to drive a car.
02:05:57 SPEAKER_016: And everybody owns a car, mainly it's a status thing, but they keep the cars parked at home.
02:06:01 SPEAKER_016: It was easier just to use the trains there in Japan.
02:06:05 SPEAKER_016: So that's one of the reasons why Japanese goods were so inexpensive because they had ships and rail inside the country that was really inexpensive.
02:06:18 SPEAKER_016: All right, mule-drawn canal boats.
02:06:20 SPEAKER_016: Someone says.
02:06:21 SPEAKER_016: So someone says, "Yep, that was a very efficient way of moving things."
02:06:25 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, it's very, very efficient.
02:06:26 SPEAKER_016: I still go.
02:06:27 SPEAKER_016: I go down to Louisville and watch the barges going up and down the Ohio River.
02:06:32 SPEAKER_016: And all kinds of stuff.
02:06:36 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, you're in a perfect place because you are connected all the way through to Lake Michigan and the Great Lakes.
02:06:42 SPEAKER_016: You wouldn't believe the shipping that goes through the Great Lakes.
02:06:45 SPEAKER_004: But those two lakes are connected, Michigan and Lake Huron.
02:06:49 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, it's twenty.
02:06:50 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, there's a twenty-kilometre-wide gap.
02:06:52 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, and over there by Niagara, there were the locks over there, and they get out to the St. Lawrence Seaway out there and get out to the Atlantic.
02:07:00 SPEAKER_016: But yeah, there are ocean-moving ships up in the Great Lakes.
02:07:04 SPEAKER_016: When I go up there, we go boating.
02:07:06 SPEAKER_016: You know, I have to avoid them to keep them from running me over.
02:07:09 SPEAKER_002: So, but yeah, I know in Owen Sound, the main issues that our harbour has silted over, and it costs six million plus to dredge it.
02:07:20 SPEAKER_002: To dredge it.
02:07:20 SPEAKER_002: Yep.
Adapting Freight Transport With Sails And Biodiesel
Speakers discuss adapting freight transport by using biodiesel for efficient rail locomotives that avoid sulfur emissions. They also describe large cargo ships deploying sails to capture trade winds and significantly reduce diesel fuel consumption. These alternative methods allow slower transit times but offer substantial cost savings for non-urgent shipments.
02:07:21 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, and we only had one company that was using the harbour, and they had six employees, and they closed just last month.
02:07:31 SPEAKER_016: What Andrew and I are talking about, life is not going to end, guys.
02:07:34 SPEAKER_016: We're just going to adapt.
02:07:35 SPEAKER_016: And there's an example of more efficient ways of shipping: waters one way, rails another.
02:07:41 SPEAKER_016: I mean, you know, it's not hard to figure out.
02:07:43 SPEAKER_016: We can look at other places that we've had.
02:07:46 SPEAKER_016: We used to extensively use rail here in America.
02:07:49 SPEAKER_016: I work for General Electric, and I know the EVO.
02:07:52 SPEAKER_016: I mean, that train, one gallon of diesel, six hundred miles, a hundred thousand tons of goods.
02:07:58 SPEAKER_016: That you can haul with an EVO.
02:08:00 SPEAKER_016: You know, so that locomotive just sipped fuel.
02:08:02 SPEAKER_016: Just really, really efficient.
02:08:06 SPEAKER_016: Let's see.
02:08:07 SPEAKER_016: We'll get back to it.
02:08:09 SPEAKER_016: But oh, here's one too, Ivor.
02:08:10 SPEAKER_016: They got sensors.
02:08:11 SPEAKER_016: You cannot buy regular diesel to burn in those.
02:08:14 SPEAKER_016: It's got to be a biodiesel.
02:08:17 SPEAKER_016: Really, it's got a sensor in there.
02:08:19 SPEAKER_016: If it senses sulfur, it shuts the engine down.
02:08:21 SPEAKER_016: You have to send one of GE's technicians to go out there to turn it on.
02:08:24 SPEAKER_016: And the reason why they did it, they made a deal with the EPA, so they don't have to put a catalytic converter in those because they burn biodiesel.
02:08:31 SPEAKER_016: Oh, okay.
02:08:33 SPEAKER_016: Oh.
02:08:34 SPEAKER_016: The biggest issue was you have all these diesel spills where you spill diesel on the ground, it contaminates a water source, but you don't have those issues with biodiesel.
02:08:43 SPEAKER_016: So the railroads made a deal with the EPA.
02:08:46 SPEAKER_016: Hey, if we switch over to biodiesel, we don't have to have the catalytic converters, and we can void all these fines from all this diesel spillage on the ground because it's a biodegradable fuel.
02:08:55 SPEAKER_016: Biodiesel.
02:08:57 SPEAKER_016: That's awesome.
02:08:59 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
02:08:59 SPEAKER_016: Well, it wasn't done for environmental guys; it just made economic sense.
02:09:03 SPEAKER_004: Well, and I think a lot of these solutions are going to make more and more economic sense as we get deeper into it.
02:09:10 SPEAKER_004: I mean, like look at that; these guys were able to go to biodiesel also because they use so little of it, you know, compared to other modes of transportation, that they could say, okay,
02:09:21 SPEAKER_004: all biodiesel.
02:09:23 SPEAKER_004: And I think you could figure out other ways of shipping things, you know, worldwide.
02:09:28 SPEAKER_004: I think especially ocean shipping, you could figure out a way, figure out ways.
02:09:32 SPEAKER_004: I would say, you know, there's ways of moving goods across the Atlantic, and I guess Michelin's already doing it with, you know, they pop up a sail in the middle.
02:09:44 SPEAKER_016: I was going to tell you that's going on out in the Pacific.
02:09:46 SPEAKER_016: Some of these guys that have the huge cargo container ships are using sails.
02:09:50 SPEAKER_016: Why not go downwind?
02:09:51 SPEAKER_016: Slow their speeds down.
02:09:53 SPEAKER_016: So that means they usually burn more diesel.
02:09:54 SPEAKER_016: But they put up a sail and their fuel consumption just drops down to nothing.
02:10:02 SPEAKER_016: And they go like the old schooner ships.
02:10:03 SPEAKER_016: They capture the trade winds.
02:10:05 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
02:10:06 SPEAKER_016: They're like these huge parachutes.
02:10:08 SPEAKER_016: Yep, huge parachute.
02:10:10 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, there's a trade wind south of Hawaii that goes from you know from California to Asia, and then north of Hawaii it goes the opposite direction.
02:10:18 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, yeah, exactly.
02:10:19 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, trade.
02:10:19 SPEAKER_004: Yeah, that's the way the Spanish galleons used to go.
02:10:23 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, and they're doing it just because it's cheaper.
02:10:26 SPEAKER_016: It's less expense, you know.
02:10:28 SPEAKER_016: And all it is is the customers have to understand.
02:10:30 SPEAKER_016: Hey, it's not going to get there in two weeks.
02:10:32 SPEAKER_016: You're going to have to wait, you know, five weeks.
02:10:34 SPEAKER_016: But you know, you save a huge amount on shipping charges.
02:10:37 SPEAKER_016: So a lot of cargos don't matter really.
02:10:39 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
02:10:41 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
02:10:41 SPEAKER_016: Take a long time.
02:10:42 SPEAKER_016: I don't know.
02:10:42 SPEAKER_016: I think.
02:10:43 SPEAKER_004: I think the, as they say, when things are at their worst, the saving power is growing also.
02:10:50 SPEAKER_004: So you just got to hope, you know, that we're figuring out something that will save us.
02:10:57 SPEAKER_004: Either I have faith in you.
02:10:59 SPEAKER_004: I have faith in David.
02:11:01 SPEAKER_016: You know, and I know this guy here, Andrew.
02:11:03 SPEAKER_016: He's trying to become a politician.
02:11:04 SPEAKER_016: I got a lot of respect for this guy.
02:11:08 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, about a glutton for punishment.
02:11:10 SPEAKER_016: I mean, but really, that's who I had faith in.
02:11:13 SPEAKER_016: I know I did it too.
02:11:14 SPEAKER_016: It was very entertaining.
02:11:15 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, being the political solution right here.
02:11:18 SPEAKER_016: This is how it's going to get done.
02:11:20 SPEAKER_016: Everybody have faith; it'll get done.
02:11:22 SPEAKER_013: Yeah, and so we'll adapt, and the human experiment will go on.
02:11:26 SPEAKER_002: Yes, yes, and someone in the comments was saying, "The rural poor are already adapted.
02:11:34 SPEAKER_002: The people inherit the earth."
02:11:34 SPEAKER_002: The meat will inherit the earth.
02:11:36 SPEAKER_002: Yes, you know.
02:11:38 SPEAKER_002: Yeah.
02:11:38 SPEAKER_002: Basically, we don't have to worry about humanity.
02:11:40 SPEAKER_002: Humanity will be fine.
02:11:42 SPEAKER_002: It's really it's the way of life of the golden billion, which is under question.
02:11:50 SPEAKER_002: Yeah, the high consumers.
02:11:52 SPEAKER_016: Well, it's just like I was talking to somebody and they're kind of lamenting about this whole thing.
02:11:57 SPEAKER_016: I think was somebody who was a stewardess worked for an airline or whatever.
02:12:00 SPEAKER_016: I said, everything will be fine.
02:12:02 SPEAKER_016: She says, what do you mean by that?
02:12:03 SPEAKER_016: I said, well, just means we're going to go back to the Titanic and the Lusitania, and that's really what will happen.
02:12:08 SPEAKER_016: So much better.
02:12:09 SPEAKER_016: Think about it.
02:12:10 SPEAKER_016: I mean, you know, those were ships that came from before the age of oil.
02:12:14 SPEAKER_016: They're like coal-powered or whatever.
02:12:15 SPEAKER_016: But the point is, is that's what will happen.
02:12:18 SPEAKER_016: Is that you won't fly planes.
02:12:19 SPEAKER_016: You just go by ship.
02:12:22 SPEAKER_016: Have a good time.
02:12:23 SPEAKER_016: Like a cruise.
02:12:23 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
02:12:25 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
02:12:26 SPEAKER_004: Well, I have friends that move around in sailboats, and they went down to you know, they got all the way down to the Caribbean.
02:12:33 SPEAKER_004: Come all the way back, you know, so they're able to, you know, do it, and they have like, you know, a little wind power thing in the back and solar panels,
02:12:41 SPEAKER_004: and just runs the whole thing.
02:12:44 SPEAKER_016: I know some a couple; they go from San Francisco all the way down to Tahiti.
02:12:50 SPEAKER_016: It takes them like six months to sail down there.
02:12:52 SPEAKER_016: They got a double catamaran to do it, and the company of the company George Buskirk, him and I, he's got a sailboat, and he's got property up in Michigan, so we sail.
02:13:00 SPEAKER_016: Of Michigan, so we sail the Great Lakes, and we go up to Lake Erie, down the St. Marys River, Lake Michigan, Huron, you know, you name it.
02:13:09 SPEAKER_016: And you know, love love to sail.
02:13:10 SPEAKER_016: I mean, that's just a fascinating, you know, way of life.
02:13:14 SPEAKER_016: You know, just not having a motor; it's just the wind and you.
Geothermal Power for Off-Grid Towns
One participant presents a formula for creating self-sufficient towns powered by geothermal energy, estimating that 55 thousand houses require one hundred megawatts of power. The speaker argues this approach provides cheap energy necessary for reindustrialization and is more affordable than commonly assumed. The discussion concludes with remarks on human nature favouring group survival over individualism before the stream ends.
02:13:17 SPEAKER_016: And sometimes the wind blows, and sometimes the storms come in.
02:13:21 SPEAKER_016: You got to roll down the sail and stick it out, stick it out through the storm.
02:13:25 SPEAKER_016: And my wife gets annoyed because I'm usually out of cell phone range.
02:13:29 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
02:13:31 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, and the customers get mad at me too.
02:13:32 SPEAKER_016: Dan, I couldn't go home for two weeks.
02:13:34 SPEAKER_016: That's because I was sailing.
02:13:35 SPEAKER_016: I told you I was going sailing.
02:13:37 SPEAKER_016: We really need you to get home.
02:13:38 SPEAKER_016: That's why I went sailing.
02:13:41 SPEAKER_016: That's why I did it.
02:13:42 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, that makes sense.
02:13:43 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, I did a lot of sailing too.
02:13:45 SPEAKER_016: Yeah, yeah.
02:13:47 SPEAKER_002: I just wanted to correct one thing.
02:13:49 SPEAKER_002: Comments they were saying survival of the fittest, and I just wanted to say it's uh, it's actually survival of the most adaptable.
02:13:58 SPEAKER_002: It goes back to the dinosaur.
02:13:59 SPEAKER_002: If you don't adapt, you become extinct.
02:14:01 SPEAKER_016: But what and everybody talks about Mad Max and the motorcycle gang and like guys.
02:14:05 SPEAKER_016: That's not how what plays out.
02:14:07 SPEAKER_016: What happens is people get together because people are more survivable in groups.
02:14:11 SPEAKER_016: We have individual skills, and if we join together and we leverage off our skills, that's how you survive.
02:14:17 SPEAKER_016: That's how you know.
02:14:19 SPEAKER_016: I was in the army and I was in the military.
02:14:21 SPEAKER_016: Teamwork.
02:14:22 SPEAKER_016: It was all about the team.
02:14:23 SPEAKER_016: There was no "I" in what we did.
02:14:25 SPEAKER_016: It was all about us.
02:14:25 SPEAKER_016: Is all about us and your team, right?
02:14:28 SPEAKER_016: And that's how people will survive.
02:14:30 SPEAKER_016: This will be.
02:14:31 SPEAKER_016: We'll go back to the city-state.
02:14:32 SPEAKER_016: This is.
02:14:33 SPEAKER_016: And that's just human nature.
02:14:34 SPEAKER_016: It's what will happen.
02:14:35 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
02:14:35 SPEAKER_016: Yeah.
02:14:36 SPEAKER_002: John Michael Greer, who we interviewed here a couple years ago, he was saying the same thing that like city of fifty thousand ish is probably the sweet spot with like a good.
02:14:47 SPEAKER_016: And then goes back when I do my geothermal presentation thing.
02:14:50 SPEAKER_016: How to take towns off?
02:14:52 SPEAKER_016: I actually have that formula.
02:14:54 SPEAKER_016: Fifty-five thousand houses, a hundred megawatts worth of power.
02:14:57 SPEAKER_016: Here's what it costs, and it's cheaper than you think it is.
02:15:00 SPEAKER_016: You know, and that's what I'm focusing on is those type of towns are actually the great towns that take them off the power grid.
02:15:08 SPEAKER_016: You know, if you want to reindustrialize, hey, I can help you out.
02:15:10 SPEAKER_016: I can show you how to do it.
02:15:13 SPEAKER_016: You know, if you know anything about manufacturing, not only have to have people, but you have to have cheap energy, and I can show you how to do that.
02:15:19 SPEAKER_016: There is a solution.
02:15:19 SPEAKER_016: Oh yeah, yeah.
02:15:23 SPEAKER_016: All right, I think we're done.
02:15:26 SPEAKER_016: Okay, yep.
02:15:27 SPEAKER_002: So thank you, everybody, for coming here today.
02:15:32 SPEAKER_002: And so as I found you, leave you in the infinite love and infinite peace of the infinite Creator within you and all around you.
02:15:39 SPEAKER_002: Therefore, I go forth therefore in the infinite power and infinite peace, my friends.
02:15:46 SPEAKER_002: All right.
02:15:46 SPEAKER_002: See you next time.
02:15:48 SPEAKER_002: Take care, guys.
02:15:49 SPEAKER_002: We'll get together.
Unofficial machine-generated transcript for convenience. Please verify against official source materials for the authoritative record.